Staccato P vs HD... Which is better?

Published on April 15, 2025
Duration: 8:12

This video compares the Staccato P and Staccato HD handguns, with the presenter, Ben Stoeger, sharing extensive experience with the P (10,000+ rounds) and moderate experience with the HD (a couple thousand rounds). While the Staccato P is described as a "plain Jane 2011" and "fine" but not "special," the HD is noted for its different grip ergonomics, lack of a grip safety, and a distinct recoil impulse that feels more neutral and returns to center faster, reminiscent of a Glock 47. The HD's trigger is also noted as a Series 70 type, not drop-safe, with a lighter pull (3.5 lbs vs. 4.5 lbs) for an extra cost.

Quick Summary

The Staccato HD offers a distinct advantage with its neutral, fast recoil impulse that returns to center quickly, feeling more balanced than the Staccato P. Its unique grip ergonomics and ability to use Glock magazines further differentiate it, making it a compelling option for those seeking a different shooting experience.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Staccato P vs HD Comparison
  2. 00:16Presenter's Experience with Staccato HD and P
  3. 00:51Internet Wisdom vs. Personal Opinion
  4. 01:11Staccato P: 'Just Another 2011'
  5. 01:34Trigger Differences: P vs HD
  6. 02:17Grip and Ergonomic Differences
  7. 03:31Recoil Impulse Comparison
  8. 04:11Staccato HD: Faster, Neutral Recoil
  9. 05:00Recoil Spring and Buffer in HD
  10. 05:33Magazine Compatibility (Glock Mags)
  11. 06:004.5 lb Trigger Version of HD
  12. 06:12Subjective Preference: Frame and Recoil
  13. 06:38Would You Buy These Guns?
  14. 06:53When to Buy a 2011: XC vs. P
  15. 07:40HD as a 'Glock Version of a 2011'
  16. 08:08Conclusion: Built for Heroes

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the Staccato P and Staccato HD?

The Staccato HD features a different grip contour for better hand protection and a more neutral, faster recoil impulse compared to the Staccato P. The HD also lacks a grip safety and can accept Glock magazines, while the P is a more traditional 2011 with a grip safety.

How does the recoil impulse of the Staccato HD compare to the Staccato P?

The Staccato HD's recoil is described as faster, more neutral, and returning to center quickly, feeling direct and well-balanced. The Staccato P, while a capable 2011, can feel slightly torquey and less soft-shooting by comparison.

What is the trigger like on the Staccato P and HD?

The Staccato P offers a 3.5 lb trigger option for an extra cost, which is a Series 70 type and not drop-safe. While the HD's trigger is noticeably different when dry firing, the practical difference during shooting is less pronounced for the presenter.

Can the Staccato HD use Glock magazines?

Yes, the Staccato HD is designed to accept OEM Glock magazines, which can be a significant advantage in terms of cost and availability compared to proprietary magazines for other 2011 platforms.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Ben Stoeger

View all →