The Truth About Handgun Stopping Power - Madman Review

Published on December 22, 2021
Duration: 7:09

This video delves into the complex topic of handgun stopping power, examining historical studies and modern testing protocols for calibers like 9mm, .40 S&W, and .45 Auto. It highlights contradictory findings from various tests, including those by LaGarde, Hatcher, the FBI, and the Strasbourg Test, ultimately concluding that shooter skill and accuracy are paramount.

Quick Summary

The video concludes that there is no simple answer to handgun stopping power. It's a complex issue heavily influenced by the shooter's skill, recoil tolerance, and accuracy, rather than solely by caliber.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Intro: Handgun Stopping Power Debate
  2. 00:52.45 Auto vs. 9mm Historical Studies
  3. 01:47.40 S&W & FBI Testing Origins
  4. 02:29The Controversial Strasbourg Test
  5. 03:139mm Hollow-Point Performance
  6. 04:32Real-World Data & Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main handgun calibers discussed regarding stopping power?

The video primarily discusses the stopping power of three major handgun calibers: 9mm Luger, .40 S&W, and .45 Auto. It examines historical and modern data comparing their effectiveness in various scenarios.

What historical studies are mentioned regarding handgun stopping power?

Key historical studies referenced include Julian Hatcher's work based on LaGarde and Thompson's tests favoring .45 Auto, and later NIJ computer models suggesting 9mm effectiveness. The Strasbourg Test and FBI protocols are also discussed.

Does the video conclude that one caliber is definitively superior for stopping power?

No, the video concludes there is no simple answer. Stopping power is complex and heavily influenced by factors beyond caliber, such as shooter skill, recoil tolerance, and accuracy.

What role does ammunition play in handgun stopping power?

Ammunition type, specifically bullet design like Jacketed Hollow Points (JHP), and performance characteristics such as velocity and expansion, are crucial. Studies identified specific 9mm JHP loads as high performers.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from BIG MAN with GUN

View all →