Why You Should NOT Buy a Sig P238 (but I kinda love mine)

Published on March 28, 2026
Duration: 5:21

This review of the Sig P238 highlights its premium build and reliable function, but ultimately advises against purchasing it as a primary EDC or backup gun. The instructor argues its all-metal construction, while contributing to shootability, makes it too heavy for common concealed carry methods like pocket or ankle carry. He also points to its limited magazine capacity and basic iron sights as significant drawbacks for its premium price point.

Quick Summary

The Sig P238 is a premium, all-metal, single-action pistol in .380 ACP, known for its reliability and 1911-like feel. However, its significant weight makes it less ideal for pocket or ankle carry, and its limited magazine capacity and basic sights are drawbacks for its price.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Why Not Buy the Sig P238
  2. 00:53The 938 Alternative
  3. 01:00P238 Backstory and Design
  4. 01:38P238's Loyal Fanbase
  5. 01:58What's Great About the P238
  6. 02:25Why I Wouldn't Buy It Again
  7. 02:30The Weight Problem
  8. 03:16Quibble 1: Magazine Capacity
  9. 03:38Quibble 2: Iron Sights
  10. 03:50Quibble 3: Price vs. Value
  11. 04:06Final Thoughts and Recommendation
  12. 04:27Personal Affection vs. Practicality
  13. 04:43Call to Action and Outro

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main reasons to avoid buying a Sig P238 for concealed carry?

The primary reasons to avoid the Sig P238 for concealed carry are its excessive weight due to its all-metal construction, making it uncomfortable for pocket or ankle carry. Additionally, its limited 6+1 or 7+1 magazine capacity and basic iron sights are considered significant drawbacks for its premium price point.

What are the positive aspects of the Sig P238 that make it appealing?

The Sig P238 is praised for its reliable function, consistently firing without issues. It also offers a premium, shootable experience with a 1911-style trigger and frame, making it attractive to those who appreciate that platform's feel and manual of arms.

How does the Sig P238 compare to other subcompact pistols for concealed carry?

Compared to polymer-framed pistols like the Ruger LCP, the P238 is significantly heavier due to its all-metal build. While this offers better shootability, it compromises its suitability for lightweight, discreet carry methods like pocket or ankle holsters.

What are the key drawbacks of the Sig P238's magazines and sights?

The standard P238 magazines hold only 6+1 rounds, with extended versions offering 7+1. The extended magazine's plastic feels cheap and poorly constructed. The iron sights are described as 'fat blocks' with no aftermarket options, limiting aiming precision and customization.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Tactical Fellowship

View all →