Why You Should NOT Buy a Sig P238 (but I kinda love mine)

Published on March 28, 2026
Duration: 5:21

This video argues against purchasing the Sig P238, despite its reliable function and 1911-like handling. The primary criticisms focus on its excessive weight for a backup or pocket gun, limited magazine capacity (6+1 or 7+1 with extension), and the perceived cheapness of the extended magazine's plastic. The iron sights are described as basic, and the overall cost is deemed too high for the compromises made. While acknowledging its cult following and the appeal of its premium build, the instructor suggests better alternatives exist for its intended roles.

Quick Summary

The Sig P238 is criticized for being too heavy for a backup or pocket gun, having limited magazine capacity (6+1 or 7+1), basic iron sights, and a high price. Despite its reliable function and premium 1911-like feel, these factors make it a less ideal choice for many concealed carry scenarios.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Intro & Channel Support
  2. 00:53P238 vs P938
  3. 00:58P238 Backstory & Design
  4. 01:58What's Great About the P238
  5. 02:27Why You Shouldn't Buy It: Weight
  6. 03:16Quibble 1: Magazine Capacity
  7. 03:38Quibble 2: Iron Sights
  8. 03:50Quibble 3: Price
  9. 04:06Final Verdict & Alternatives
  10. 04:51Outro & Philosophy

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main reasons not to buy a Sig P238?

The primary reasons are its excessive weight for a backup or pocket gun, limited magazine capacity (6+1 or 7+1), basic iron sights with no aftermarket options, and a high price point for its perceived compromises. The extended magazine is also criticized for its cheap construction.

Is the Sig P238 reliable?

Yes, the speaker states the Sig P238 has functioned flawlessly for them, firing every time without issues, even with early production models. Its reliability is not a point of criticism.

What are the pros of the Sig P238?

The Sig P238 is praised for its all-metal, single-action build that offers a premium feel and 1911-like handling. It's noted for its shootability and has a loyal fanbase.

What are better alternatives to the Sig P238 for concealed carry?

While not explicitly named as 'better' alternatives, the speaker suggests that for its intended role as a backup gun, there are 'almost invisible options' that are lighter. The Sig P938 is also mentioned as a related alternative.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Tactical Fellowship

View all →