Calling the Shots | Alien Gear Holsters

Published on February 27, 2020
Duration: 57:40

This video breaks down the legal framework for using defensive force, focusing on the 'Five Elements of Self-Defense': Innocence, Imminence, Proportionality, Avoidance, and Reasonableness. It analyzes various scenarios, including armed robbery, to illustrate how these elements apply in determining whether a 'shoot' is lawful. The discussion emphasizes the importance of understanding the law to avoid criminal charges, even when acting in perceived self-defense, and highlights the difference between legal justification and tactical decision-making.

Quick Summary

The five elements of self-defense law are Innocence, Imminence, Proportionality, Avoidance, and Reasonableness. These legal conditions determine if the use of defensive force, including deadly force, is lawful. Understanding these elements is crucial for lawful self-defense and avoiding criminal charges.

Chapters

  1. 01:33Introduction and Welcome
  2. 03:00Alien Gear Live Broadcast
  3. 04:16How the Show Works: Video Analysis
  4. 05:00The 5 Elements of Self-Defense Explained
  5. 08:31Scenario 1: Initial Threat Perception
  6. 16:25Scenario 1 Continued: Verbal Demands
  7. 20:58Scenario 1 Continued: Weapon Displayed
  8. 23:34Knife vs. Firearm Threats
  9. 25:00Robbery: Property vs. Person Crimes
  10. 27:04Duty to Retreat Analysis
  11. 31:30Scenario 2: Off-Duty Officers Intervene
  12. 34:22Fake Gun vs. Real Gun Legal Analysis
  13. 35:26Scenario 2: Non-Law Enforcement Intervention
  14. 41:45Scenario 2 Continued: Tactical Separation
  15. 47:26Scenario 2 Continued: Suspect Drops Gun and Flees
  16. 51:47Scenario 2: Law Enforcement vs. Civilian Pursuit
  17. 55:05Resources and Call to Action

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the five elements of self-defense law?

The five elements of self-defense law are Innocence (you are not the aggressor), Imminence (the threat is about to happen), Proportionality (the force used is equal to the threat), Avoidance (you have no safe duty to retreat), and Reasonableness (your perception of the threat is reasonable).

Can I use deadly force if the attacker has a fake gun?

Yes, you can generally use deadly force if a reasonable person would perceive the fake weapon as real. The law allows you to treat the threat as credible based on its appearance and the attacker's actions, not based on your ability to discern its authenticity.

Is it lawful to shoot someone running away?

Generally, it is not lawful to shoot someone running away if they are no longer an imminent threat and have dropped their weapon. However, if you are unaware they dropped the weapon, or if they pose a continued threat, the situation may differ. Police officers have different rules for pursuit and arrest.

What is the difference between a lawful shoot and a good idea?

A 'lawful shoot' means the use of force meets the legal requirements of self-defense. A 'good idea' or 'tactically sound' decision involves considering practical outcomes, such as company policy, personal safety beyond the immediate threat, or potential legal entanglements unrelated to self-defense.

Related News

All News →

More Self Defense Videos You Might Like

More from Alien Gear Holsters

View all →