6 Reasons 9mm USUALLY BEATS Thirty-Eight Special!

Published on May 24, 2026
Duration: 14:34

This video, presented by Ted from Line 4-5, argues that 9mm handguns generally outperform .38 Special revolvers for most civilian concealed carriers. The primary reasons cited are higher ammunition capacity in modern compact 9mm pistols, more manageable recoil due to increased weight and better ergonomics, superior modern defensive ammunition performance, faster and simpler reloads, and a more robust aftermarket ecosystem for accessories and training. While acknowledging the .38 Special's niche for deep concealment or backup roles, the presenter emphasizes that 9mm offers a more forgiving platform for the average shooter, providing more room for error and a greater likelihood of successful defensive encounters.

Quick Summary

For most civilian concealed carriers, 9mm handguns generally outperform .38 Special revolvers due to higher ammunition capacity in compact pistols, more manageable recoil, superior modern defensive ammunition performance, and faster, simpler reloads. The extensive aftermarket support and significantly cheaper practice ammunition for 9mm also make it a more practical and accessible choice for developing essential defensive skills.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Intro: Revolver Simplicity vs. Practicality
  2. 00:16Reason 1: Capacity Advantage of 9mm
  3. 01:01Reason 2: Recoil Management and Shootability
  4. 02:22Reason 3: Modern 9mm Ammunition Performance
  5. 03:10Reason 4: Faster and Simpler Reloads
  6. 04:55Reason 5: The 9mm Ecosystem Advantage
  7. 05:22Reason 6: Affordable Practice Ammunition
  8. 06:15.38 Special's Niche Roles
  9. 07:01Conclusion: 9mm as the Smarter Default

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is 9mm generally considered better than .38 Special for concealed carry?

9mm handguns typically offer higher ammunition capacity in compact sizes, more manageable recoil due to better ergonomics and semi-automatic action, superior performance from modern defensive ammunition, and faster, simpler reloads. The robust aftermarket support and cheaper practice ammo also make 9mm a more practical choice for most civilian carriers.

What are the main advantages of modern 9mm defensive ammunition?

Modern 9mm defensive rounds, like Federal HST or Speer Gold Dot, are engineered for consistent expansion, effective penetration through common barriers, and reliable performance. This represents a significant improvement over older ammunition designs and provides better terminal ballistics, especially from shorter barrels found in concealed carry firearms.

How does the reload process differ between 9mm semi-automatics and .38 Special revolvers?

Reloading a 9mm semi-automatic is typically a direct magazine swap, which is quick and intuitive. In contrast, reloading a .38 Special revolver involves more steps: opening the cylinder, ejecting casings, and loading rounds individually or with a speed loader/strip, making it a slower and more complex process, especially under stress.

Why is the cost of ammunition a significant factor in choosing between 9mm and .38 Special?

The cost difference for practice ammunition is substantial. 9mm range ammo can cost around $0.16-$0.22 per round, while .38 Special practice ammo is often $0.39-$0.42 per round. This makes frequent and realistic training with 9mm far more affordable, leading to better shooter proficiency.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from Line45

View all →