Are Glock 19's Compact? (What makes a Compact Gun?)

Published on March 14, 2015
Duration: 6:05

TheYankeeMarshal, an established firearms commentator, provides an analytical breakdown of what defines a 'compact' handgun, arguing that grip length and thickness are more critical than barrel length. He uses the Glock 19 and Sig Sauer P229 as primary examples, classifying the Glock 19 as a large compact and the P229 as a small full-size pistol due to its substantial grip dimensions compared to true compacts and even other full-size models. Viewers are encouraged to physically handle these firearms to grasp the differences in scale.

Quick Summary

TheYankeeMarshal argues that grip length and thickness, not just barrel length, define a handgun's classification. He places the Glock 19 at the upper end of compacts due to its thin grip, while the Sig Sauer P229 is considered a 'small full-size' because its grip is thick and comparable in length to larger models.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to the Compact vs. Full-Size Debate
  2. 01:20Defining 'Compact' Firearms
  3. 02:39Analyzing the Sig P229
  4. 03:54Conclusion and Final Comparisons

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the Glock 19 considered a compact pistol?

According to TheYankeeMarshal, the Glock 19 is at the upper limit of the compact category. He emphasizes that while its barrel is relatively short, its grip length and thin profile make it a large compact, rather than a subcompact or mid-size option.

What are the key factors in determining if a handgun is compact?

The primary factors determining if a handgun is compact are its grip length and grip thickness, not solely its barrel length. A compact firearm will have reduced dimensions in these areas compared to a full-size model, aiding concealability.

Why is the Sig Sauer P229 not considered a true compact by some experts?

The Sig Sauer P229, despite having a shorter barrel than some full-size pistols, is often considered a 'small full-size' because its grip is thick and its length is nearly identical to larger pistols like the Sig P226, making it less concealable than typical compacts.

How does grip thickness affect handgun classification?

Grip thickness is a crucial factor in classifying handguns. A thicker grip, even on a pistol with a shorter barrel, can make it feel and handle more like a full-size firearm and be more difficult to conceal effectively for everyday carry (EDC).

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →