Mud Test: WW1 & WW2 P08 Luger

Published on April 18, 2016
Duration: 7:54

This video details a practical mud test on a WW1/WW2 P08 Luger, challenging the common belief that these firearms are unreliable in adverse conditions. Presenters Ian McCollum and Karl Kasarda demonstrate the Luger's functionality after being completely submerged in mud, firing 16 rounds without malfunction. The analysis highlights the Luger's well-sealed action as a key factor in its surprising resilience, while also touching on ammunition sensitivity and the complexity of its historical manufacturing.

Quick Summary

The P08 Luger, despite its historical reputation, proved surprisingly reliable in a mud test, firing 16 rounds after being fully submerged. Experts attribute this resilience to its well-sealed action, which keeps critical components free from debris. While ammo-sensitive, its performance debunks myths of inherent unreliability in adverse conditions.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: P08 Luger Mud Test
  2. 00:47Baseline Test and Preparation
  3. 01:20Mud Immersion
  4. 01:47Post-Mud Firing Test
  5. 02:34Analysis of Results
  6. 03:32Ammo Sensitivity and Maintenance
  7. 04:37Manufacturing and Design Complexity
  8. 07:24Bonus Shooting Footage

Frequently Asked Questions

How reliable is the P08 Luger in muddy conditions?

In a practical mud test, the P08 Luger fired 16 rounds (two full magazines) after being completely submerged in thick mud, demonstrating 100% reliability. This challenges the common myth of its unreliability in adverse conditions.

Why was the P38 adopted over the P08 Luger?

While the P38 replaced the P08 Luger, experts suggest the switch was likely driven more by manufacturing costs and production efficiency than by significant reliability issues with the Luger, especially considering the Luger's performance in tests like this.

What makes the P08 Luger's action resilient to mud?

The P08 Luger's action is well-sealed when in battery. This design feature effectively prevents mud and debris from entering the critical internal components, allowing it to function reliably even after being heavily fouled.

Are P08 Lugers sensitive to ammunition type?

Yes, P08 Lugers can be ammo-sensitive. They often require 'hotter' ammunition, such as NATO specification or Winchester White Box, to cycle reliably, particularly if fitted with new, factory-standard springs.

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from InRangeTV

View all →