Passive or Active Retention Best for EDC Holster!?!

Published on May 12, 2025
Duration: 14:20

This video explores the choice between passive and active retention holsters for everyday carry. The speaker, TheYankeeMarshal, leans towards passive leather holsters for comfort but acknowledges the potential need for active retention in certain scenarios, especially with Outside the Waistband (OWB) carry. He highlights that the choice depends on the firearm, individual experience, and the specific carry environment.

Quick Summary

Passive retention holsters rely on friction and holster shape, while active retention holsters use mechanical devices like buttons or thumb breaks. The choice depends on firearm type, carry method (IWB vs. OWB), and personal preference for comfort and security.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to Holster Retention
  2. 00:35Defining Passive vs. Active Retention
  3. 01:25YankeeMarshal's Preference: Passive Leather
  4. 02:18Personal Incident & Retention Concerns
  5. 03:02Viewer Input: Edgar Cortez on Gun Type & Experience
  6. 04:03Viewer Input: Ernesto Castillo on Caliber Strength
  7. 04:39Viewer Input: DM Foul on Tussling & Retention
  8. 06:00Viewer Input: Practical Bacon on Passive Holsters
  9. 06:13Dangers of Certain Active Retention Holsters
  10. 06:40Viewer Input: Ghost Shadow on IWB vs. OWB Retention
  11. 07:18Personal Experience Losing a Gun
  12. 08:23Viewer Input: Mr. Furley Open to Active Retention
  13. 08:44Viewer Input: Gummy Wuzzle Wants All Retention
  14. 09:44Viewer Input: Nominal Snowman's Lanyard Carry
  15. 10:36Viewer Input: Spark 680 Back Pocket Carry
  16. 11:19Viewer Input: DM FA on Intervention Timing
  17. 12:09Legal Update on Attacker
  18. 12:26Concluding Thoughts & Viewer Engagement

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between passive and active retention holsters?

Passive retention holsters hold a firearm using friction and the holster's shape, often gripping the trigger guard. Active retention holsters require a deliberate action, like pressing a button or releasing a thumb break, to draw the firearm.

Which type of holster is better for concealed carry?

Inside the Waistband (IWB) holsters are generally preferred for concealed carry due to their ability to hide the firearm more effectively. The retention type (passive or active) then depends on personal preference and the specific firearm.

Can active retention holsters be dangerous?

Yes, some active retention holsters, especially those with trigger retention, can be dangerous with firearms that have very light triggers. There's a risk of accidental discharge if the retention mechanism is inadvertently engaged during reholstering.

Does the type of gun affect holster retention choice?

Yes, the firearm's trigger pull weight and overall design can influence holster choice. Light triggers may necessitate caution with certain active retention systems to prevent accidental discharges.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →