Testing an Original WW1 Trench Gun w/ GI Buckshot: How Does it Pattern?

Published on September 29, 2023
Duration: 18:01

This video provides an expert analysis of the Winchester 1897 Trench Gun's performance with original WWI-era buckshot. Featuring Ian McCollum and Matt Haught, it details historical ammunition challenges and compares vintage patterning with modern advancements like Federal FliteControl. The analysis includes practical tests at 10 and 25 yards, shell dissections, and a 'wetproof' test, offering valuable insights into firearm and ammunition evolution.

Quick Summary

Vintage buckshot patterns from WWI-era ammunition are significantly less consistent and wider than modern loads like Federal FliteControl. This difference is attributed to advancements in wad technology, pellet plating, and hull materials, which improve aerodynamic stability and reduce pellet deformation for tighter, more predictable shot strings.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: WWI Trench Gun & Ammo
  2. 00:30Ammunition History: Paper vs. Brass Hulls
  3. 01:41Technical Expectations: Vintage Ammo Performance
  4. 03:0610-Yard Patterning: Vintage vs. Modern Barrel
  5. 05:22Modern Comparison: Federal FliteControl Test
  6. 06:16Wad Technology Explained
  7. 07:4725-Yard Patterning: Vintage Ammo Spread
  8. 11:16Shell Dissection: Vintage vs. Modern Components
  9. 13:07Waterproof Testing: Vintage Paper Shells

Frequently Asked Questions

How does vintage buckshot pattern compared to modern buckshot?

Vintage buckshot, like the Remington Kleanbore tested, typically produces wider and less consistent patterns, especially at range. Modern buckshot, such as Federal FliteControl, utilizes advanced wad technology to achieve significantly tighter and more predictable groupings, even at 10 yards.

What are the key differences between vintage and modern shotgun shells?

Vintage shells often used paper hulls and fiber wads with unplated lead pellets, prone to deformation and moisture issues. Modern shells feature plastic hulls, advanced plastic wads (like FliteControl), buffered powder, and often copper-plated shot for improved consistency, durability, and ballistic performance.

Why did WWI trench environments affect ammunition?

Trench environments were often wet and muddy. Paper hulls on ammunition could swell when wet, causing chambering and extraction issues. This led to a transition towards more moisture-resistant materials like brass for certain ammunition types during and after WWI.

What is the 'donut effect' in shotgun patterns?

The 'donut effect' describes a shotgun pattern where the pellets form a ring or 'donut' shape, with fewer pellets hitting the center area. This is often characteristic of older ammunition designs or specific choke constrictions at certain distances, indicating inconsistent pellet flight.

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →