UpLula vs. Butler Creek Magazine Speed Loaders. Which is Best?

Published on May 19, 2019
Duration: 10:25

This guide details the use of pistol magazine speed loaders, specifically comparing the Maglula UpLula and Butler Creek ASAP. Based on 15 years of field experience and competitive use, the Maglula UpLula is presented as the more reliable and efficient option, particularly for single-stack magazines. The process involves placing the loader over the feed lips and pressing down to insert rounds, with the UpLula demonstrating a significant speed advantage.

Quick Summary

The Maglula UpLula is the superior pistol magazine speed loader, offering approximately 40% faster loading times compared to the Butler Creek ASAP. With 15 years of proven reliability in competitive shooting and compatibility across single and double-stack magazines (9mm to .45 ACP), the UpLula is the recommended choice for efficiency and durability.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Speed Loader Comparison
  2. 01:24Baseline: Hand Loading Glock Magazine
  3. 02:11Head-to-Head Speed Test
  4. 03:45Performance Analysis & Reliability
  5. 05:29Market & Price Comparison
  6. 08:33Single-Stack Magazine Test

Frequently Asked Questions

Which pistol speed loader is faster, the Maglula UpLula or the Butler Creek ASAP?

The Maglula UpLula is significantly faster, completing the loading task approximately 40% quicker than the Butler Creek ASAP. In testing, the UpLula loaded a magazine in 53 seconds, while the ASAP took 1 minute and 28 seconds.

Is the Butler Creek ASAP compatible with single-stack magazines?

No, the Butler Creek ASAP is not reliably compatible with single-stack magazines. Testing showed it failed to function, causing the follower to dig into the plastic, unlike the Maglula UpLula which works adequately.

What are the key advantages of the Maglula UpLula?

The Maglula UpLula offers superior speed, proven reliability over 15 years of use (including competition), better ergonomics, and compatibility with both single and double-stack magazines for calibers ranging from 9mm to .45 ACP.

How much do the Maglula UpLula and Butler Creek ASAP speed loaders typically cost?

Prices can vary, but the Maglula UpLula was shown to be slightly less expensive, around $27.94 on Amazon, while the Butler Creek ASAP was priced around $28.75 during the comparison.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from DEUCE AND GUNS

View all →