Are Single Stack Handguns Obsolete?

Published on May 30, 2021
Duration: 15:56

This video features an expert-level analysis of whether single-stack handguns are obsolete, presented by James Reeves. A timed accuracy drill was conducted at St. Bernard Indoor Shooting Center with ten shooters of varying backgrounds, comparing the Smith & Wesson Shield, Shield Plus, and M&P 2.0 Subcompact. The Shield Plus demonstrated superior performance in both objective scoring and subjective shooter preference for concealed carry.

Quick Summary

The S&W Shield Plus offers a compelling alternative to traditional single-stack handguns, boasting higher capacity (11 rounds) and slightly less weight (20.1 oz) than the original Shield. Its improved trigger and ergonomics led to superior performance in timed accuracy drills, making it a top choice for concealed carry.

Chapters

  1. 00:43The Rise of Micro-Compacts
  2. 01:40Shield vs. Shield Plus Comparison
  3. 02:31Experimental Methodology
  4. 03:13Technical Specs and Weight
  5. 04:07The Shooting Test
  6. 11:01Data Analysis and Results

Frequently Asked Questions

Are single-stack handguns still relevant in today's market?

While micro-compacts with double-digit capacities like the Sig P365 and Springfield Hellcat have gained popularity, single-stacks like the S&W M&P Shield remain viable, especially for deep concealment. Performance tests show modern micro-compacts often outperform older single-stacks in accuracy drills.

What are the key differences between the S&W Shield and Shield Plus?

The Shield Plus offers higher capacity (11 rounds vs. 8 rounds for the Shield), slightly less weight (20.1 oz vs. 20.3 oz), and a similar slide width. Crucially, the Shield Plus features an improved trigger and better ergonomics, making it a preferred choice for many users.

How did the S&W Shield Plus perform in a timed accuracy drill?

In a drill requiring 7 rounds at 7 yards in 7 seconds, the Shield Plus achieved the highest average score among tested firearms, indicating strong performance under simulated stress. It was also the subjective favorite for carry.

What factors make a micro-compact handgun suitable for concealed carry?

Key factors include a slim profile, manageable weight, sufficient capacity for self-defense, reliable function, and good ergonomics. The trigger quality and ease of manipulation under stress are also critical considerations.

Related News

All News →

More Training & Techniques Videos You Might Like

More from TFB TV

View all →