Does it Even Matter? Which Gun Should You Carry?

Published on September 17, 2023
Duration: 21:23

This video compares the performance of a micro-compact Sig P365 against a full-size Staccato XC in three key concealed carry drills. Instructor Brett tests whether the gun choice significantly impacts marksmanship under pressure. While both firearms passed the drills, the Staccato XC demonstrated an average 14-round faster completion time, highlighting potential advantages in high-stress scenarios.

Quick Summary

Instructor Brett tests if your concealed carry firearm impacts performance. Comparing the Sig P365 and Staccato XC in drills, the Staccato XC showed an average 14-round faster completion time, highlighting potential advantages in split times during high-stress encounters, though fundamentals remain paramount.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Carry Gun Debate
  2. 00:49Testing the Carry Gun Theory
  3. 01:15The Contenders: Sig P365 vs. Staccato XC
  4. 03:09Online Coaching Course Announcement
  5. 04:08Ammunition Sponsor: True Shot
  6. 04:38Concealed Carry Drills Explained
  7. 04:50Drill 1: The Bill Drill
  8. 06:26Drill 2: The 5x5 Drill
  9. 07:24Drill 3: The FBI Qualification
  10. 10:41FBI Qualification Results & Analysis
  11. 11:26Key Difference: Split Times
  12. 12:33Is Speed Worth the Compromise?
  13. 13:13Threat Scenarios & Firearm Needs
  14. 15:54Split Times vs. Group Size
  15. 16:06Sig P365 Sights: Pros & Cons
  16. 17:00Red Dot vs. Iron Sights
  17. 19:34Advice: Fundamentals Over Gear
  18. 19:59The Compromise: Glock 19 Size
  19. 20:31Advanced Pistol Fundamentals Course
  20. 20:53Thank You & Outro

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the type of gun you carry for concealed carry make a difference in performance?

Yes, it can. While fundamental skills are paramount, a larger, more shootable firearm like the Staccato XC demonstrated an average 14-round faster completion time in drills compared to a micro-compact Sig P365, indicating potential advantages in split times during high-stress encounters.

What are the key concealed carry drills recommended for assessing marksmanship?

Three essential drills are the Bill Drill (speed and recoil control), the 5x5 Drill (accuracy under time pressure), and the FBI Qualification (marksmanship across various distances). Passing these from concealment indicates a solid foundation for defensive shooting.

Are red dot sights necessary for effective concealed carry?

Red dot sights offer advantages in precision and target acquisition, especially at distance, and enhance tactical awareness. However, for the majority of defensive encounters, iron sights are sufficient, though a dot can be beneficial in more complex or uncommon scenarios.

What is the instructor's philosophy on choosing a concealed carry firearm?

The instructor's philosophy is to be prepared for the most challenging encounters. If you can effectively handle a larger, faster firearm, you are more than adequately prepared for common threats. Fundamentals of pistol shooting are considered the most critical factor.

Related News

All News →

More Training & Techniques Videos You Might Like

More from Nightwood Guns

View all →