Reloads - Slide Stop or Over the Top???

Published on October 13, 2018
Duration: 6:16

This video explores the 'slide stop' versus 'over the top' pistol reload debate, concluding both are valid. John Lovell argues against the 'fine motor skill' critique of the slide stop, while Don Edwards favors the 'over the top' for its universality. Jon Dufresne demonstrates a left-handed slide stop technique. Ultimately, consistency and a logical reason for choice are paramount, with the slide stop offering a slight speed advantage.

Quick Summary

The 'slide stop' reload is often slightly faster and more consistent than the 'over the top' method, especially when performed with a 'one-two' rhythm. However, both techniques are valid, and the 'over the top' method is recommended for beginners due to its universality across different firearm states and models.

Chapters

  1. 00:09Intro: Reload Debate
  2. 01:09Debunking Fine Motor Skill Argument
  3. 01:55Why 'Over the Top' Reloads Work
  4. 02:59Why 'Slide Stop' Reloads Work
  5. 04:42Left-Handed Slide Stop Technique
  6. 05:13Live Fire Comparison & Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the two main pistol reload techniques discussed?

The two primary pistol reload techniques debated are the 'slide stop' method, where the slide release lever is used to chamber a round, and the 'over the top' or 'overhand rack' method, where the slide is manually pulled back to chamber a round.

Is the slide stop reload a fine motor skill that fails under stress?

While some argue it is, experts like John Lovell contend that operating a firearm involves many complex skills. If a shooter cannot operate the slide stop, they likely have more fundamental issues with weapon manipulation under pressure.

Which pistol reload method is generally considered faster?

The 'slide stop' reload is generally considered slightly faster than the 'over the top' method, especially when executed with a consistent 'one-two' rhythm (insert magazine, then hit the slide stop) to prevent binding.

What is the 'over the top' reload method recommended for?

The 'over the top' reload is often recommended for new shooters because it's a universal technique that works regardless of whether the slide is locked back or forward, and it functions effectively across different firearm models.

More Training & Techniques Videos You Might Like

More from Warrior Poet Society

View all →