Revolver vs Semi Auto: One in the Chamber Explained

Published on March 3, 2026
Duration: 1:30

This video, featuring an experienced instructor, compares the speed of engaging a target from a draw with a non-chambered semi-auto, a chambered semi-auto (specifically mentioning the Sig P320), and a revolver. The drill demonstrates that revolvers are fastest, followed by chambered semi-autos, and then non-chambered semi-autos. The instructor highlights the tactical disadvantage of carrying a semi-auto without a round in the chamber due to the added time to rack the slide, which can be critical in self-defense scenarios. For those uncomfortable carrying a chambered semi-auto, revolvers are presented as a viable alternative.

Quick Summary

A draw-to-first-shot test reveals revolvers are fastest, followed by chambered semi-autos, and then non-chambered semi-autos. Carrying a semi-auto chambered is recommended for tactical readiness, though revolvers offer an alternative for those uncomfortable with chambered semi-autos.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Revolver vs. Semi-Auto Carry
  2. 00:18Carrying Without a Chambered Round
  3. 00:31Revolver Advantage Explained
  4. 00:44Draw and Fire Test Results

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between carrying a semi-auto 'chambered' versus 'non-chambered'?

Carrying 'chambered' means a round is already in the handgun's chamber, ready to fire. 'Non-chambered' means the chamber is empty, requiring the user to rack the slide to load the first round, which adds critical time.

Which handgun type is fastest from a draw to the first shot?

According to the test, revolvers are the fastest, followed by chambered semi-automatic handguns. Non-chambered semi-automatic handguns are the slowest due to the time needed to rack the slide.

Why might someone prefer carrying a revolver over a semi-auto?

Some individuals are uncomfortable carrying a semi-automatic handgun with a round in the chamber due to safety concerns. Revolvers, when loaded, are inherently ready to fire and may offer peace of mind to these users.

What is the tactical disadvantage of carrying a non-chambered semi-auto?

The primary disadvantage is the delay in deploying the firearm. The time taken to rack the slide can be critical in a self-defense situation, potentially costing valuable seconds when immediate action is needed.

Related News

All News →

More Training & Techniques Videos You Might Like

More from CajunBoyJake

View all →