Semi-Auto Shotgun vs Semi-Auto Rifle — Who Clears Faster?

Published on October 1, 2025
Duration: 20:55

This video demonstrates a timed challenge comparing the speed of deploying rounds from a semi-automatic rifle (Sig Sauer M400 in 5.56) versus a semi-automatic shotgun (Beretta 1301 Tactical in 12 gauge). The focus is on the shooter's ability to fire all rounds as quickly as possible, starting from a low-ready position. The instructor highlights the impact of recoil and ammunition velocity on shooting speed, noting that faster shotgun loads can increase recoil and potentially affect reliability.

Quick Summary

In a timed mag dump challenge comparing a Sig Sauer M400 rifle and a Beretta 1301 Tactical shotgun, the rifle generally cleared faster. The rifle's best time was 1:88, while the shotgun's best was 2:23. Recoil and ammunition velocity significantly impact shotgun speed, with lighter loads potentially affecting reliability.

Chapters

  1. 00:15Introduction: Speed Challenge
  2. 00:20Understanding Projectile Speed vs. Deployment Speed
  3. 00:41The Challenge: AR vs. 12 Gauge
  4. 00:53Firearms Used: Sig M400 & Beretta 1301 Tactical
  5. 01:40The Role of Recoil in Shooting Speed
  6. 02:25Safe Shooting Environment: Imly Range
  7. 03:11Preparation and Gear Up
  8. 03:33AR-15 Setup: 7 Rounds of 5.56
  9. 04:03Starting from Low Ready: AR Challenge
  10. 04:30AR Mag Dump Time: 2:02
  11. 04:49Shotgun Setup: 8 Rounds of 12 Gauge
  12. 05:34Shotgun Challenge: Low Ready
  13. 05:54Shotgun Mag Dump Time: 2:71
  14. 06:05Initial Reaction to Shotgun Recoil
  15. 06:21Comparing Initial Times: AR vs. Shotgun
  16. 06:43Second AR Run: Predicting the Time
  17. 07:02AR Mag Dump Time: 2:41 (Slower)
  18. 07:19Analyzing the AR Performance Drop
  19. 07:46Switching to Lighter Shotgun Loads (1400 FPS)
  20. 08:12Second Shotgun Run: Lighter Loads
  21. 08:23Shotgun Mag Dump Time: 2:69 (Improved)
  22. 08:31First Shot Speed Comparison
  23. 08:45Impact of Recoil on the Shooter
  24. 08:52Third AR Run: Aiming for Improvement
  25. 09:14AR Mag Dump Time: 2:09 (Slightly Slower)
  26. 09:21First Shot Speed: AR vs. Shotgun
  27. 09:43The Humbling Nature of Speed Challenges
  28. 10:00Reloading for Another Shotgun Attempt
  29. 10:25Goal: First Shot Under 1 Second
  30. 10:44Fourth Shotgun Run
  31. 10:59Shotgun Mag Dump Time: 2:67 (Improved)
  32. 11:03First Shot Speed Improvement
  33. 11:17Considering Lighter Loads Again
  34. 11:57Fifth AR Run: Sig M400
  35. 12:21AR Mag Dump Time: 1:90 (Best AR Time)
  36. 12:54Shotgun Finickiness with Lighter Loads
  37. 13:18Trying 1290 FPS Loads in the Shotgun
  38. 13:30Anticipating Potential Malfunctions
  39. 14:22Sixth Shotgun Run: 1290 FPS Loads
  40. 14:32Shotgun Mag Dump Time: 2:30 (Good Time)
  41. 14:34First Shot Speed with 1290 FPS Loads
  42. 14:56Comparison: 1400 FPS vs. 1290 FPS Shotgun Loads
  43. 15:19Reloading for Another AR Attempt
  44. 15:37Timed Mag Dumps: AR Focus
  45. 16:15Seventh AR Run
  46. 16:15AR Mag Dump Time: 2:21 (Hiccup)
  47. 16:24Trigger Reset Hiccup Explained
  48. 16:59Eighth Shotgun Run: Aiming for Improvement
  49. 17:27Shotgun Mag Dump Time: 2:24 (Similar to AR)
  50. 17:38AR vs. Shotgun Performance Analysis
  51. 18:04Ninth AR Run: Final Push
  52. 18:26AR Mag Dump Time: 1:88 (Best Overall Time)
  53. 19:02Tenth Shotgun Run: Beretta 1301 Tactical
  54. 19:20Shotgun Mag Dump Time: 2:23
  55. 19:36Reflections on Speed Shooting
  56. 19:58The Value of Repetition and Practice
  57. 20:07Future Improvements Expected
  58. 20:32Conclusion: Timed Mag Dumps are Fun
  59. 20:43Thank You and Call to Action

Frequently Asked Questions

Which firearm cleared faster in the timed mag dump challenge: the semi-auto rifle or the semi-auto shotgun?

In the timed mag dump challenge, the semi-automatic rifle (Sig Sauer M400 in 5.56) generally cleared faster than the semi-automatic shotgun (Beretta 1301 Tactical in 12 gauge). The rifle's best time was 1:88, while the shotgun's best time was 2:23.

What factors influence the speed of shooting a semi-automatic shotgun?

The speed of shooting a semi-automatic shotgun is significantly influenced by recoil management and ammunition velocity. Higher FPS loads increase recoil, which can slow down follow-up shots and potentially affect the shotgun's cycling reliability.

Can lighter loads affect the reliability of a semi-automatic 12 gauge shotgun?

Yes, semi-automatic 12 gauge shotguns can be finicky with lighter or lower-powered loads. Using ammunition that is too weak may lead to cycling issues or malfunctions, impacting the overall speed and effectiveness of the firearm.

What is the significance of the first shot time in a speed challenge?

The time it takes for the first shot to leave the barrel is crucial in speed challenges. In some instances during the test, the first shot from the 12 gauge shotgun was faster than the first shot from the AR-15, highlighting the importance of initial presentation and trigger break.

Related News

All News →

More Training & Techniques Videos You Might Like

More from Yoki Sturrup

View all →