"Uncommanded Discharge" is NOT a Thing!!!

Published on September 17, 2025
Duration: 9:03

The video argues that 'uncommanded discharge' is not a valid firearms term, instead advocating for the use of 'negligent discharge' for user error and 'malfunction' for mechanical failures. It emphasizes that most firearm incidents stem from user error, not inherent firearm defects, and highlights the importance of understanding the distinction for accountability and safety.

Quick Summary

The term 'uncommanded discharge' is widely considered inaccurate in firearms terminology. Experts distinguish between 'negligent discharge,' which results from user error, and 'malfunction,' a mechanical failure. Most firearm incidents stem from user error, not inherent defects in the weapon.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Is 'Uncommanded Discharge' Real?
  2. 00:18The Yankee Marshal's Stance
  3. 00:48Defining Uncommanded Discharge
  4. 01:04Negligent Discharge vs. Malfunction
  5. 01:54What is a Malfunction?
  6. 02:05Example: Remington 700 Incident
  7. 03:12Sig P320 and Glock Incidents
  8. 03:48Dropping a Firearm: User Error vs. Malfunction
  9. 04:16Drop Safety and Firing Pin Blocks
  10. 05:06Why 'Uncommanded Discharge' is Unnecessary
  11. 05:32Historical Context of Firearm Incidents
  12. 06:01Glock Reliability Over Time
  13. 06:19Safety Concerns with Striker-Fired Guns
  14. 06:36Harm from Malfunction vs. Negligence
  15. 07:07The Only Two Terms Needed
  16. 07:25Manipulative Language in Firearms Discussion

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between a negligent discharge and a malfunction?

A negligent discharge occurs when a firearm fires due to user error, meaning it operated as intended but was handled improperly. A malfunction, however, is when the firearm fires because it operated in a way it was not designed to, indicating a mechanical failure.

Why is the term 'uncommanded discharge' considered problematic in firearms discussions?

The term 'uncommanded discharge' is problematic because it conflates two distinct issues: user error (negligent discharge) and mechanical failure (malfunction). This ambiguity can muddy accountability, making it unclear whether the fault lies with the user or the firearm manufacturer.

Are most firearm incidents caused by malfunctions or user error?

According to firearms instructors, approximately 99.9% of firearm incidents are caused by user error, categorized as negligent discharges, rather than actual malfunctions of the firearm's mechanical components.

What safety features are important to consider regarding dropped firearms?

If a firearm has safety features like a firing pin block or drop safety and still fires when dropped, it's considered a malfunction. However, if a firearm lacks these features and fires upon impact, it's classified as user error or negligent discharge.

Related News

All News →

More Training & Techniques Videos You Might Like

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →