Your Gun Training Is Useless Past 10 Yards?

Published on December 11, 2025
Duration: 7:46

Colion Noir critically examines the controversial claim that firearm training beyond 20 rounds or 7-10 yards is ineffective. He uses real-world defensive encounters and personal experience to argue for a balanced approach, suggesting that while close-range proficiency is paramount, completely neglecting longer distances is a mistake. The video emphasizes that individual learning styles and specific defensive needs should dictate training regimens.

Quick Summary

Colion Noir critically examines the debate around firearms training effectiveness beyond 10 yards. While acknowledging that most gunfights occur at very close range, he presents real-world defensive incidents where engagements happened at 15 and even 40 yards, arguing that completely neglecting longer distances is a mistake for civilian training.

Chapters

  1. 00:00The 20-Round Controversy
  2. 01:15Training Distance Debate
  3. 02:25Real-World Counter-Examples
  4. 03:55Repetition and Skill Acquisition
  5. 05:30The Workout Analogy

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the argument against training firearms past 10 yards?

The argument, popularized by figures like John 'Shrek' McPhee, suggests that human focus degrades significantly after about 20 rounds, making extensive training beyond 7-10 yards inefficient, as most gunfights occur at very close distances (around 3 yards).

What evidence supports training beyond 10 yards for self-defense?

Real-world incidents like the Greenwood Park Mall shooting, where Eli Dicken engaged a threat from 40 yards, and the White Settlement, Texas church shooting, where Jack Wilson engaged from 15 yards, demonstrate that effective defensive actions can occur at distances greater than 10 yards.

How does Colion Noir reconcile different training philosophies?

Colion Noir acknowledges the importance of close-range training as a foundational skill but argues against completely dismissing longer distances. He emphasizes that individual learning styles and the potential for defensive encounters at various ranges necessitate a more comprehensive training approach.

What is the analogy used to describe firearms training distances?

Firearms training is compared to a gym workout. Close-range training is considered the 'compound movement' or core strength, while longer-range precision shooting is viewed as 'accessory work,' suggesting both have their place in a well-rounded fitness and training regimen.

Related News

All News →

More Training & Techniques Videos You Might Like

More from Colion Noir

View all →