9th Circuit Rules U.S. Constitution Does NOT Grant the Right to Carry! (INISDE GUNS w/TYM S2:E58)

Published on March 25, 2021
Duration: 15:17

The Ninth Circuit's en banc ruling in Young v. Hawaii determined that the U.S. Constitution does not grant an individual the right to openly carry a firearm in public. This decision specifically impacts Hawaii's restrictive carry laws and does not negate existing concealed or open carry rights in other states. The speaker suggests this ruling may be appealed to the Supreme Court, which could lead to a national standard on carry rights.

Quick Summary

The Ninth Circuit ruled in Young v. Hawaii that the U.S. Constitution does not grant an individual the right to openly carry a firearm in public. This decision specifically impacts Hawaii's restrictive gun laws and does not negate existing concealed or open carry rights in other states. The case may be appealed to the Supreme Court, potentially setting a national standard.

Chapters

  1. 00:17Introduction & Studio Setup
  2. 01:03Ninth Circuit En Banc Hearing on Young v. Hawaii
  3. 01:40Hawaii's Restrictive Carry Laws
  4. 02:20Ruling: No Right to Open Carry in Public
  5. 02:27Addressing Viewer Panic & Misinformation
  6. 03:00Impact on States with Existing Carry Rights
  7. 04:01Comparison to California's Situation
  8. 04:10Clarification: Not a Total Ban on Carrying
  9. 04:32Reasoning: Historical Restrictions on Open Carry
  10. 04:47Court's Decision on Concealed Carry Aspect
  11. 05:34Dissenting Judges' Arguments
  12. 06:32Misinterpretation of Dissenting Opinions
  13. 06:36Consensus on Carry Rights Precedent
  14. 07:04Impact on Different States
  15. 07:16Supreme Court's Role
  16. 07:54Skepticism Towards Supreme Court Justices
  17. 08:46Optimism for Supreme Court Review
  18. 09:07Significance of Dissenting Judges
  19. 09:40Activist Judges vs. Constitutional Interpretation
  20. 10:00Contradictory Rulings Explained
  21. 10:47Stalling Tactics by the Court
  22. 11:03Put Up or Shut Up Time for Supreme Court
  23. 11:13Blessing in Disguise: National Impact
  24. 12:07Supreme Court Victory Potential
  25. 12:30Longer Wait for Some States
  26. 13:06Potential for National Carry Rights
  27. 13:49Good News for New Jersey & New York
  28. 14:03Fund the Fight: Young v. Hawaii
  29. 14:36Don't Despair: Future Outlook

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the Ninth Circuit's ruling in Young v. Hawaii regarding gun carry rights?

The Ninth Circuit, in an en banc hearing, ruled that the U.S. Constitution does not grant individuals the right to openly carry a firearm in public. This decision specifically impacts Hawaii's restrictive gun laws.

Does the Ninth Circuit's ruling mean I can no longer carry a gun?

No, this ruling primarily affects Hawaii's specific laws and does not negate concealed or open carry rights in other states. If your state already permits concealed or open carry, this ruling likely does not affect your ability to do so.

What are Hawaii's gun carry laws that led to the Young v. Hawaii case?

Hawaii requires individuals to demonstrate a 'need' and good character to obtain a concealed carry permit, and open carry is generally prohibited. This makes it very difficult for most citizens to legally carry firearms in the state.

Could the Young v. Hawaii case go to the Supreme Court?

Yes, the speaker believes the case is likely to be appealed to the Supreme Court. A Supreme Court review could establish a national standard for firearm carry rights, potentially impacting all states.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →