Gun Gripes #143: "HR38 + HR4477 = NO DEAL!!!

Published on December 5, 2017
Duration: 8:06

Iraqveteran8888's Eric and Chad express strong opposition to HR 38 (Concealed Carry Reciprocity) being bundled with HR 4477 (Fix NICS). They argue that HR 4477, by incentivizing states to report more individuals to NICS, undermines due process and disproportionately affects law-abiding citizens, including veterans, while failing to prevent prohibited persons from acquiring firearms. The bundling is seen as a political tactic to kill national reciprocity.

Quick Summary

Iraqveteran8888 experts explain that bundling HR 38 (Concealed Carry Reciprocity) with HR 4477 (Fix NICS) is a political 'dirty pool' tactic. HR 4477 is criticized for eroding due process and potentially flagging law-abiding citizens, including veterans, without enhancing safety, thus sabotaging the passage of national reciprocity.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: HR38 & HR4477 Bundling Crisis
  2. 01:30The 'Dirty Pool' of Legislative Bundling
  3. 02:25Concerns with HR4477 'Fix NICS'
  4. 03:00Lack of Due Process & Financial Incentives in HR4477
  5. 04:30Impact on Veterans & Erroneous Reporting
  6. 05:40Political Support & Warnings on HR4477
  7. 07:10Call to Action for Gun Owners

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is the bundling of HR 38 and HR 4477 considered problematic by gun rights advocates?

Gun rights advocates view the bundling of HR 38 (Concealed Carry Reciprocity) with HR 4477 (Fix NICS) as a political tactic. They believe HR 4477, which pressures states to report more individuals to NICS, undermines due process and is used to kill the popular HR 38 bill.

What are the main criticisms of the HR 4477 'Fix NICS' bill?

Critics argue HR 4477 incentivizes states to report more names to NICS, potentially flagging law-abiding citizens erroneously without improving safety. Concerns include the erosion of due process and the creation of a 'guilty until proven innocent' scenario.

How might HR 4477 negatively impact veterans?

Veterans are a concern because HR 4477's broad reporting requirements could lead to them being unfairly added to NICS for reasons like PTSD or minor financial issues, potentially prohibiting them from owning firearms.

What is the 'dirty pool' tactic mentioned regarding HR 38 and HR 4477?

The 'dirty pool' tactic refers to combining a desirable bill (HR 38, Concealed Carry Reciprocity) with a controversial or detrimental bill (HR 4477, Fix NICS). This forces legislators to vote against the entire package to reject the problematic part, effectively killing the desired legislation.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Iraqveteran8888

View all →