Is owning a Gun a Right or a Privilege; Ruger LCR; Leupold Optics Go to DC: Gun Talk Radio|7.23.17

Published on July 24, 2017
Duration: 44:24

This episode of Gun Talk Radio delves into the fundamental distinction between constitutional rights and government-granted privileges, using the right to bear arms (Second Amendment) and the privilege of driving as a primary comparison. Host Tom Gresham and callers argue that rights are inherent and protected from government infringement, while privileges are granted by the state and can be revoked. The discussion highlights the offensive nature of requiring licenses, tests, or registration for exercising constitutional rights, drawing parallels to potential infringements on First Amendment freedoms.

Quick Summary

Owning a gun is a constitutional right protected by the Second Amendment, meaning it's an inherent freedom the government cannot infringe upon. Driving, conversely, is a privilege granted by the state, which can impose conditions and revoke it. Applying requirements like licenses or tests to constitutional rights is seen as an infringement, similar to how such requirements for free speech would be unacceptable.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & Crimson Trace Ad
  2. 00:26Show Introduction & Topics
  3. 01:00Guest Introduction: Lawyer Filing Lawsuit
  4. 02:43The Scarlet Letter for Gun Owners: Michigan Case
  5. 04:44Listener Mail: Right vs. Privilege Debate Begins
  6. 05:31Matt's Comparison: Driving vs. Gun Ownership
  7. 06:20Black Hills Ammunition Ad
  8. 06:52Springfield Armory Concealed Carry Training Ad
  9. 07:21FN 509 Handgun Ad
  10. 08:01US Sportsman Alliance Ad
  11. 08:26SureFire Tactical Lights Ad
  12. 09:07Range Report: Ruger LCR with Crimson Trace Laser
  13. 12:24Caller Question: Concealed Carry Holster & Seatbelts
  14. 15:07Deb's Take: Driver's License vs. Gun Rights
  15. 16:01Tom Gresham Explains Right vs. Privilege
  16. 16:33Comparing Rights: First Amendment vs. Second Amendment
  17. 19:04Money's Take: God-Given Rights & Historical Parallels
  18. 19:57Reacting to 'Overreacting' Claims
  19. 20:25Computer Purchase Analogy
  20. 21:33Understanding the Gun Rights Movement
  21. 22:27Commercial Break & Newsletter Ad
  22. 23:02Made in America Week: Leupold Optics at the White House
  23. 31:04Anthony Scaramucci's Gun Control Stance
  24. 33:16Terry's Question: Gun Safes & Selling Reloading Press
  25. 36:34John's Take: Reloading Press Sales & Driver's License Analogy
  26. 39:47Gun Sales Trends & Background Checks
  27. 40:47Chuck's Question: AR-10 Stock Comfort
  28. 44:03Stock Fit & Optics Discussion

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the fundamental difference between a gun right and a driving privilege?

The core distinction is that owning a gun is a constitutional right, protected by the Second Amendment, meaning it's an inherent freedom the government cannot infringe upon. Driving, however, is a privilege granted by the state, which can impose conditions and revoke it.

Why do gun owners find comparisons to driving privileges offensive when discussing gun rights?

Gun owners find it offensive because it equates an inherent constitutional right, like the Second Amendment, with a state-granted privilege like driving. They argue that applying requirements like licenses or tests to constitutional rights is an infringement, similar to how such requirements for free speech would be unacceptable.

How is the Bill of Rights interpreted in the context of gun rights?

The Bill of Rights is seen not as a list of rights given by the government, but as a declaration of pre-existing rights that the founding fathers sought to protect from government overreach. These rights are considered fundamental and 'out of bounds' for government infringement.

What is the significance of the FBI background check for gun purchases?

The FBI background check for firearm purchases is highlighted as an example of government involvement that gun owners find problematic. They argue that such a check, akin to requiring an FBI check to buy a computer, is an unnecessary hurdle for exercising a constitutional right.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Gun Talk Media

View all →