Janine Turner from Constituting America on the Second Amendment

Published on March 7, 2012
Duration: 12:13

This video features Janine Turner of Constituting America discussing the Second Amendment. Key takeaways include the historical concerns about standing armies, the importance of the militia, the impact of Supreme Court decisions like Heller and McDonald, and the potential threat to Second Amendment rights from future judicial appointments. The discussion also touches on the political framing of issues like the Obamacare mandate and its relation to religious liberty.

Quick Summary

Janine Turner of Constituting America emphasizes the Second Amendment's role in protecting other liberties, noting that dictatorships historically disarm citizens first. She highlights concerns that future Supreme Court appointments could jeopardize gun rights, referencing the vulnerability of 5-4 decisions in cases like Heller and McDonald. The discussion also touches on the historical fear of standing armies and the importance of the militia.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction of Janine Turner
  2. 00:37Constituting America's 90-Day Forum
  3. 01:13Focus on the Second Amendment
  4. 01:22Writers on the Second Amendment
  5. 02:10Learnings about the Second Amendment
  6. 02:25Militia vs. Standing Army
  7. 03:17Supreme Court Decisions & Crime Rates
  8. 04:03Practical Implications of Gun Ownership
  9. 04:26Second Amendment Protecting First Amendment
  10. 04:53Importance of 2012 Election for 2nd Amendment
  11. 06:01Judicial Appointments and Second Amendment Risk
  12. 06:26Militia and State Rights
  13. 06:54Overturning Supreme Court Decisions
  14. 07:14Legislative Branch and Amendments
  15. 08:32Political Double Standards & Distractions
  16. 09:02Take on Political Double Standard
  17. 09:43Infringement of Religious Liberty
  18. 10:19Liberty vs. 'Gimme Gimme' Culture
  19. 10:57Disturbing Political Discourse
  20. 11:20Media Spin and Distractions
  21. 11:47Importance of Studying the Bill of Rights
  22. 11:59Conclusion and Future Programs

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Constituting America's approach to studying the US Constitution?

Constituting America hosts a 90-day forum where they delve into the US Constitution and its amendments. Each year focuses on a different aspect, with recent years examining the Federalist Papers, the Constitution itself, and now specifically the Amendments, including extensive study of the First and Second Amendments.

How does Janine Turner view the historical context of the Second Amendment regarding standing armies?

Janine Turner highlights that the founding fathers and Anti-Federalists were deeply concerned about standing armies being used against the people, similar to practices under monarchs. This concern underscores the importance of an armed citizenry and the role of the militia as a counterbalance.

What is the connection between the Second Amendment and the First Amendment, according to Janine Turner?

Janine Turner argues that the Second Amendment is pivotal in protecting the First Amendment. She explains that in historical dictatorships, the first action taken by a tyrant is to disarm the populace, thereby paving the way for the suppression of other rights, including freedom of speech and religion.

What are the concerns regarding future Supreme Court appointments and the Second Amendment?

There is a significant concern that future Supreme Court appointments could lead to the re-litigation and potential erosion of Second Amendment rights. A 5-4 decision in key cases like Heller and McDonald means that a shift in even one justice could fundamentally alter the interpretation and protection of the right to keep and bear arms.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from NRA

View all →