National Right-to-Carry Bill Under Attack

Published on September 27, 2011
Duration: 6:36

This video discusses HR 822, the National Right-to-Carry Reciprocity Act of 2011, and addresses criticisms from groups like Mayors Against Illegal Guns and the Brady Campaign. It clarifies that the bill aims to ensure reciprocity for legal concealed carry permits across state lines, refuting claims of federal licensing, registration, or the destruction of constitutional carry. The discussion highlights the constitutional basis for federal legislation, including the 14th Amendment and the Interstate Commerce Clause, to protect Second Amendment rights.

Quick Summary

HR 822, the National Right-to-Carry Reciprocity Act, aims to ensure that legal concealed carry permits are recognized across state lines. It is based on the constitutional authority of the 14th Amendment and the Interstate Commerce Clause, and does not create federal licensing or registration systems.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to HR 822
  2. 00:16NRA Fact Sheet and Opposition
  3. 00:44Criticisms: States' Rights
  4. 01:17Response to States' Rights Argument
  5. 02:01Constitutional Basis: 14th Amendment
  6. 02:31Constitutional Basis: Interstate Commerce
  7. 03:14Myth: Federal Licensing/Registration
  8. 04:49Myth: Destroying Constitutional Carry
  9. 05:32Myth: Attaching Anti-Gun Amendments
  10. 06:14Legislative Timeline

Frequently Asked Questions

What is HR 822, the National Right-to-Carry Reciprocity Act?

HR 822 is a proposed federal bill that aims to establish national reciprocity for concealed carry permits. It would require states to recognize concealed carry permits issued by other states, ensuring that individuals legally allowed to carry a concealed handgun in one state are recognized in others.

What are the main criticisms against HR 822?

Key criticisms include the argument that HR 822 infringes on states' rights to enact their own gun laws. Opponents also express concerns about potential federal licensing or registration systems and the impact on constitutional carry, though proponents refute these claims.

What constitutional arguments support HR 822?

Proponents cite the 14th Amendment, which allows Congress to pass legislation protecting citizens' rights against state intrusion. The Second Amendment, as incorporated against states by the Heller and McDonald decisions, and the Interstate Commerce Clause are also cited as bases for federal authority.

Does HR 822 create a federal gun registry or licensing system?

No, HR 822 does not create a federal licensing or registration system. The bill's intent is to ensure that valid concealed carry permits issued by states are recognized nationwide, requiring only the permit and identification for reciprocity.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from NRA

View all →