NOW: Circuit Split On 18-20 Year Old Bans... Judge ROASTS Everytown For Hints Of Racism, Sexism, etc

Published on June 18, 2025
Duration: 8:07

This video discusses the Fourth Circuit's ruling upholding the federal ban on handgun sales to individuals aged 18-20 in McCoy v. ATF. It highlights the dissenting opinion from Judge Quattlebaum, who argued the ban violates the Second Amendment and noted that Everytown's amicus brief's logic could exclude voters based on age, property, race, or gender, drawing parallels to historical disenfranchisement. The ruling creates a circuit split with the Fifth Circuit, potentially leading to Supreme Court review.

Quick Summary

The Fourth Circuit upheld the federal ban on handgun sales to 18-20 year olds in McCoy v. ATF, creating a circuit split with the Fifth Circuit. Judge Quattlebaum's dissent criticized Everytown's arguments, noting their logic could exclude voters based on age, property, race, or gender, mirroring historical disenfranchisement.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Freedom vs. Control
  2. 00:21Host Introduction & Channel Mission
  3. 00:33Judge Calls Out Gun Control Group
  4. 00:44Circuit Split on 18-20 Year Old Bans
  5. 01:26Breaking News: Fourth Circuit Ruling
  6. 01:42McCoy v. ATF Case Details
  7. 01:55Judge Richardson's Dissent
  8. 02:04Supreme Court and Circuit Splits
  9. 02:27Circuit Split on Handgun Bans
  10. 02:36Fourth Circuit Upholds Under-21 Ban
  11. 02:50Everytown Accused of Racism/Sexism
  12. 03:09Firearms Policy Coalition Highlights
  13. 03:35Judge Quattlebaum's Dissenting Opinion
  14. 04:21Judge Quattlebaum on Everytown's Brief
  15. 04:41Historical Disenfranchisement Arguments
  16. 05:02Court Document Excerpt: 1791 Context
  17. 05:38The Problem with Historical Logic
  18. 06:06Gun Controllers' Dilemma
  19. 06:44Founding Era Voting Limitations
  20. 07:02Everytown's Selective Arguments
  21. 07:38Leaning on Discrimination for Gun Control
  22. 07:46Circuit Split Heading to SCOTUS
  23. 07:56Call to Action & Outro

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the significance of the Fourth Circuit's ruling on 18-20 year old handgun bans?

The Fourth Circuit upheld the federal ban on handgun sales to 18-20 year olds in McCoy v. ATF. This ruling creates a circuit split with the Fifth Circuit, meaning different federal circuits have conflicting interpretations, which often prompts the Supreme Court to review the case.

What criticisms were made of Everytown's arguments in the 18-20 year old gun ban case?

Judge Quattlebaum criticized Everytown's amicus brief, stating its logic for excluding 18-20 year olds based on voting age in 1791 could also exclude individuals based on property ownership, race, or gender, drawing parallels to historical disenfranchisement.

Why is the historical context of voting rights relevant to the Second Amendment debate?

The debate hinges on whether 'the people' protected by the Second Amendment are defined by historical voting rights. Arguments that 18-20 year olds are excluded because they couldn't vote in the 18th century are countered by pointing out that many groups, including women and minorities, were also disenfranchised then.

What does a 'circuit split' mean for gun rights litigation?

A circuit split occurs when different federal appellate courts (circuits) issue conflicting rulings on the same legal issue. This disagreement signals a potential need for the U.S. Supreme Court to step in and provide a definitive interpretation of the law or constitutional right.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Langley Outdoors Academy

View all →