Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee on Right-to-Carry Reciprocity

Published on November 17, 2011
Duration: 12:37

This video discusses the debate surrounding HR 22, the National Right to Carry Reciprocity Act, and an amendment proposed by Representative Sheila Jackson Lee. The amendment aimed to create a national database of concealed carry permit holders and require 24-hour advance notice to law enforcement when individuals with permits travel to another state. Opponents argued this amendment would burden law-abiding citizens, treat permit holders as criminals, and create a practical and constitutional nightmare, while proponents emphasized law enforcement safety and the need for better information during traffic stops.

Quick Summary

The National Right to Carry Reciprocity Act (HR 22) aims to standardize concealed carry laws across states. An amendment proposed by Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee sought to require 24-hour advance notification to law enforcement in a new state and create a national database of permit holders, citing law enforcement safety concerns.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to the Debate
  2. 00:13Rep. Jackson Lee's Initial Argument
  3. 00:58Critique of Jackson Lee's Argument
  4. 01:31Concerns about Stolen Guns and National Concealed Carry Law
  5. 03:21Jackson Lee's Amendment Details
  6. 03:27Example of Law Enforcement Officer Fatality
  7. 05:00Amendment's Goal: Law Enforcement Protection
  8. 05:09Database and Notification Requirements
  9. 06:28Exchange with Rep. Gouty
  10. 07:03Jackson Lee's Family and Safety Argument
  11. 08:06Amendment's Specifics: Advance Notice
  12. 08:41Hypothetical Traffic Stop Scenario
  13. 09:21Inlet System Limitations
  14. 10:14Rep. Gouty's Opposition to Amendment
  15. 10:21Treating Permit Holders as Criminals
  16. 10:54Practicality and Constitutional Concerns
  17. 11:15Questions on Law Enforcement Action with Data
  18. 12:11Infringement on Right to Travel and Self-Defense

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the National Right to Carry Reciprocity Act (HR 22)?

The National Right to Carry Reciprocity Act, or HR 22, is a proposed federal law that would allow individuals who legally possess a concealed carry permit in one state to carry concealed firearms in other states, provided they comply with the laws of the state they are visiting.

What was Representative Sheila Jackson Lee's proposed amendment to HR 22?

Representative Sheila Jackson Lee proposed an amendment that would require individuals with concealed carry permits to provide 24 hours' advance notice to law enforcement in another state before carrying a concealed handgun there. It also sought to create a national database of permit holders accessible to law enforcement.

What were the main arguments against Sheila Jackson Lee's amendment?

Opponents argued the amendment would treat law-abiding permit holders as criminals, create a practical nightmare for travelers, infringe on constitutional rights, and that criminals would not comply with notification requirements, rendering it ineffective for safety.

What was the primary justification for Sheila Jackson Lee's amendment?

The primary justification offered was to enhance the safety of law enforcement officers by providing them with advance notice and access to a database of individuals carrying concealed weapons during traffic stops or other encounters.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from NRA

View all →