Supreme Court ILLEGALLY Starts Emergency Order For Gun Control!

Published on January 5, 2025
Duration: 12:07

This video discusses the legal challenges to New York's gun laws, specifically focusing on the SRA v. City of New York case. It highlights how the Supreme Court's Bruin decision impacts discretionary licensing schemes and 'good moral character' requirements for firearm permits. The analysis explains the denial of emergency review by the Supreme Court and the ongoing legal battles in lower courts.

Quick Summary

The Supreme Court denied emergency review in SRA v. City of New York, a case challenging New York City's discretionary gun permit process and 'good moral character' requirements. This decision allows the Second Circuit to proceed with its review, aligning with the Supreme Court's preference for merits-based decisions from lower courts.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Federal Judge Suspends NY Gun Law Provisions
  2. 00:05Supreme Court Ruling on NY Gun Law Challenge
  3. 00:10NY Raising Age for Semi-Automatic Rifles
  4. 00:15Prohibition of Semi-Automatic Rifles & High-Capacity Magazines
  5. 00:24Concealed Carry Law Constitutionality
  6. 00:28NYS Rifle and Pistol Association Lawsuit
  7. 00:46SRA v. City of New York Case Overview
  8. 01:02Issues with NY's Permit Requirement
  9. 01:17Good Moral Character Determination
  10. 01:24Defiance of Supreme Court's Bruin Ruling
  11. 01:40Bruin Decision on May Issue CCW Licensing
  12. 01:50No Historical Support for May Issue Arms Possession Permit
  13. 02:00Lawsuit Sprung from Bruin Decision
  14. 02:14Federal Judge Suspends Key NY Gun Law Provisions
  15. 02:19NY Lawmakers Overhaul Handgun Licensing
  16. 02:25Ban on Body Armor for Civilians
  17. 02:27License to Purchase Semi-Auto Rifles
  18. 02:33Supreme Court Decision Undoing Law
  19. 02:42Bruin Decision's Primary Findings
  20. 02:51Clarence Thomas on Proper Cause Standard
  21. 03:22Bruin Decision Rejected Proper Cause Standard
  22. 03:33Plaintiffs Using Bruin to Attack Good Moral Character Requirement
  23. 03:48Plaintiff Joseph Sar Challenges NY City's Licensing Scheme
  24. 03:57District Court Granted Permanent Injunction
  25. 04:11US Supreme Court Major Ruling on NY Gun Law
  26. 04:15Individual Wanted to Carry Concealed Weapon
  27. 04:24Supreme Court Struck Down NY Law
  28. 04:28NY New Gun Registration Law
  29. 04:36Significant Win for Lower Federal Court
  30. 04:47City of New York Filed Appeal to Second Circuit
  31. 04:56New York Sought Stay on Injunction
  32. 05:03Second Circuit Granted Stay
  33. 05:06Emergency Application Filed to Supreme Court
  34. 05:14Arguments for Removing Stay
  35. 05:21Lower Court Ruled in Favor of Plaintiffs
  36. 05:34City of New York Likely to Lose on Appeal
  37. 05:3710 New Bills to Strengthen State's Gun Laws
  38. 05:39Applicants Show Gun Use Understanding
  39. 05:43Safeguarding Guns When Not in Use
  40. 05:45Proper Cause Requirement by NYPD
  41. 05:53Hold on New Illinois Law Banning High Power Semi-Automatic Weapons
  42. 05:59Supreme Court Should Step In
  43. 06:05Argument on Second Circuit's Reliance on Antonyuk Case
  44. 06:15Antonyuk Not Binding on Appeal
  45. 06:24Merits-Based Determination in SRA Case
  46. 06:27Supreme Court Denies Emergency Review
  47. 06:30SRA Appeal is Merit Review
  48. 06:36Antonyuk in Interlocutory Posture
  49. 06:42Interesting Aspects of Antonyuk and SRA Case
  50. 06:47Second Circuit Stated Bruin Was Exceptional Case
  51. 06:58Second Circuit Claims No Need to Follow Bruin
  52. 07:05Second Circuit Relying on Antonyuk is a Failure
  53. 07:14Proof Should Not Have Been Used
  54. 07:18Supreme Court Ought to Intervene
  55. 07:21Disobedience to Supreme Court Rulings
  56. 07:24Emergency Application Filed with Justice Sotomayor
  57. 07:31Justice Responsible for Second Circuit Filings
  58. 07:34Jennifer Johnson on New Rules
  59. 07:40US Supreme Court Struck Down NY Handgun Laws
  60. 07:44Required Good Reason to Carry
  61. 07:47Supreme Court: Cannot Require Justification for Concealed Carry
  62. 07:51Purpose of Second Amendment
  63. 07:57NY Raising Age for Semi-Automatic Rifles to 21
  64. 08:05Justice Sotomayor Denied Emergency Application
  65. 08:09Did Not Submit to Full Court
  66. 08:14Emergency Applications Process
  67. 08:25Plaintiffs Could Submit Renewal Application
  68. 08:37Justice Thomas Accepted Application
  69. 08:41Referred to Full Court Conference
  70. 08:46Law Prohibits Possession, Manufacture, Sale of Semi-Automatic Rifles
  71. 08:50High-Capacity Magazines
  72. 08:53Threatening Mass Harm a Crime
  73. 08:55Strengthen State's Red Flag Laws
  74. 08:58Supreme Court Asked to Block Illinois Assault Weapons Ban
  75. 09:03Protect Illinois Communities Act
  76. 09:05Bans Specific Brands/Types of Rifles and Handguns
  77. 09:10NYS Rifle and Pistol Association Lawsuit
  78. 09:16SRA Case Went to Supreme Court for Conference
  79. 09:21Other Second Amendment Cases
  80. 09:23Bianche Maryland Attack Weapon Ban Case
  81. 09:25Illinois Rifle Ban Cases
  82. 09:30Order List from Supreme Court
  83. 09:34Denied Emergency Review
  84. 09:36Bianche Case Denial
  85. 09:41What Does This Mean?
  86. 09:43Is This Case Dead in the Water?
  87. 09:46Supreme Court Denied Emergency Application
  88. 09:51Supreme Court Does Not Traditionally Like Reviewing These Cases
  89. 09:56Seeking Reversal of State Order
  90. 09:58Unusual Emergency Applications
  91. 10:05Prefer Final Merits Reviews and Circuit Court Splits
  92. 10:11Interim Stay Order by Second Circuit
  93. 10:14Second Circuit Still Reviewing Appeal
  94. 10:18Issue Their Own Merits Determination
  95. 10:20Legal Challenges Aimed at Concealed Carry Rules
  96. 10:27New Rules Take Effect September 1st
  97. 10:33Particularized Need for Concealed Carry Permit
  98. 10:42Refuse to Surrender Right to Protect New Yorkers
  99. 10:46Decision on Concealed Carry Law Coming
  100. 10:54Supreme Court Likely Decided Not to Get Involved
  101. 10:56Letting Second Circuit Issue Merits Decision
  102. 11:03Lot of Development Left in This Case
  103. 11:09Supreme Court Decided to Punt
  104. 11:12Waiting for New Supreme Court Decision on Second Amendment
  105. 11:17Opinion on Rahimi Case
  106. 11:20Waiting for Decision in Rahimi
  107. 11:24Application of Bruin to Federal Law
  108. 11:27Domestic Crime Restraining Orders
  109. 11:29Huge Implications for Other Second Amendment Cases
  110. 11:34Supreme Court's Current Mindset: Punt All Cases
  111. 11:39Wait for Rahimi Decision
  112. 11:43Let Lower Courts Apply Rahimi
  113. 11:47Dealing with Potential Complications
  114. 11:54Not Great News
  115. 11:56Sarer Case is Not Dead in the Water
  116. 11:59Wait to See How Second Circuit Rules
  117. 12:01End of Video

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the SRA v. City of New York case about?

The SRA v. City of New York case challenges New York City's discretionary licensing scheme for acquiring rifles and shotguns. Plaintiffs argue that the 'good moral character' requirement for permits is unconstitutional and violates the Supreme Court's Bruin decision, which struck down similar discretionary processes.

Why did the Supreme Court deny emergency review in the SRA v. City of New York case?

The Supreme Court typically prefers to review cases after a final merits decision from the circuit courts or when there's a circuit split. Denying emergency review allows the Second Circuit to issue its own ruling first, which the Supreme Court may then consider.

What is the significance of the Bruin decision for New York gun laws?

The Bruin decision established that firearm regulations must have historical support and struck down New York's 'proper cause' standard for concealed carry permits. This ruling impacts discretionary licensing and 'good moral character' requirements for gun ownership and carry in New York.

What are the implications of the Supreme Court's denial of emergency review for gun rights advocates?

While not a victory, the denial means the legal battle continues in lower courts. Gun rights advocates are awaiting the Second Circuit's decision and potentially future Supreme Court review, especially after the upcoming Rahimi case ruling.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Best Iron

View all →