This Week in Guns 11/22/23 - It's Thankstaking Time, Based Judges, and AR15 Lies

Published on November 22, 2023
Duration: 58:48

A Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals panel has struck down Maryland's handgun permit purchase requirements, citing the Bruen decision. The court found the state's arguments for historical analogs insufficient. This ruling is a significant victory for Second Amendment advocates, though it is subject to appeal.

Quick Summary

A Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals panel has struck down Maryland's handgun permit purchase requirements, ruling that the state's justifications were insufficient under the Bruen decision's historical standard. The decision is stayed for 14 days pending potential appeals.

Chapters

  1. 06:00Maryland Gun Law Update
  2. 06:09Fourth Circuit Court Ruling
  3. 06:18Striking Down Permit Requirements
  4. 06:31Everytown's Reaction
  5. 06:54Court's Interpretation of Bruen
  6. 07:44Appeal Process Explained
  7. 09:31Everytown's Statement
  8. 10:14State's Analogies Rejected
  9. 11:02Protest Permit Comparison
  10. 11:37Constitutional Balancing
  11. 12:06NRA Discussion
  12. 13:15Colt's Downfall Analogy
  13. 14:31Advocacy Organization Dynamics
  14. 15:41Rat Analogy
  15. 16:09Mr. Wang Discussion
  16. 16:48Trusting Gun Advocacy Groups
  17. 17:53Damaging Concessions
  18. 19:13Maryland Shall Issue Plug
  19. 20:21Gatekeeping Gun Ownership
  20. 21:05Bad Concessions by Lawyers
  21. 21:17Staples Decision Dicta
  22. 22:02M16 vs AR-15 Debate
  23. 23:24Firearm Pattern Recognition
  24. 24:38The Black Rifle Book
  25. 25:29Supporting Gun Groups
  26. 26:03FFL Payment Solutions
  27. 27:32Philadelphia Inquirer Article
  28. 28:20Gun Buybacks Don't Cut Crime
  29. 29:59Wrong Guns Recovered
  30. 31:03Alternative Crime Stopping Ideas
  31. 32:00Incentivizing Police Tips
  32. 32:30Shooting Last Night
  33. 32:54Gun Buyback Longevity
  34. 35:00Improving Gun Buybacks
  35. 36:00Destroying Historical Firearms
  36. 37:40Washington Post Photo Controversy
  37. 38:15Terror on Repeat Article
  38. 39:31Washington Post's Angle
  39. 41:34Invented Terminology
  40. 42:03Washington Post Editorial
  41. 43:06Washington Post as Troll
  42. 43:34Bloomberg Ties
  43. 44:08MAFCORP Black Friday
  44. 45:27Crap Post Posts Headline
  45. 46:02Federal Money for Gun Safety
  46. 46:354-H and NRA Connection
  47. 47:014-H Program Explained
  48. 48:18NRA's Role in Safety Training
  49. 49:46Patriot Patch Company
  50. 50:51Oregon Measure 114 Blocked
  51. 51:10Harney County Judge's Decision
  52. 51:35Measure 114 Details
  53. 52:38Oregon's Judicial System
  54. 53:21Republicans and Black Gun Ownership
  55. 53:31NBC Poll on Gun Ownership
  56. 54:44Shifting Gun Ownership Demographics
  57. 56:00African-American Gun Ownership Increase
  58. 56:30Political Stances on Gun Bans
  59. 57:01Patriot Patch Company Recap
  60. 57:44Show Wrap-up
  61. 57:55Thanksgiving Wishes

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the outcome of the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals ruling on Maryland's handgun permit requirements?

The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals struck down Maryland's handgun permit purchase requirements. The court found that the state's historical justifications for these requirements were insufficient under the Bruen decision's standard for Second Amendment challenges.

How did the court's decision in Maryland relate to the Bruen decision?

The court's ruling heavily relied on the Bruen decision, emphasizing the need for historical tradition to justify firearm regulations. The judges found Maryland's arguments for historical analogs to be weak and not comparable to the modern permit requirements.

What are the next steps for Maryland's handgun permit law after the Fourth Circuit ruling?

The ruling is stayed for 14 days, giving Maryland the opportunity to appeal. The state can seek review from the full Fourth Circuit (en banc) or petition the U.S. Supreme Court for further consideration of the case.

What was the reaction from gun control advocacy groups to the Maryland ruling?

Groups like Everytown for Gun Safety criticized the decision, with their deputy director of Second Amendment litigation stating that background checks and safety training are common sense and consistent with the Second Amendment. They believe the ruling is dangerous and misguided.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Fudd Busters

View all →