Washington D.C. Warms to Gun-Toting Tourists

Published on September 25, 2012
Duration: 8:48

This video discusses proposed changes to Washington D.C.'s gun laws, specifically a bill aimed at decriminalizing unintentional violations by non-residents. The bill, introduced by Council Chairman Phil Mendelson, would allow for administrative fines instead of criminal charges for non-residents caught with unregistered firearms or ammunition, a significant shift from current strict regulations that have led to arrests of military personnel for minor infractions. The discussion highlights the unique and extreme nature of D.C.'s gun laws compared to other jurisdictions and the ongoing legal challenges to them.

Quick Summary

Washington D.C. is considering a bill to decriminalize unintentional gun and ammunition law violations for non-residents, potentially replacing criminal charges with administrative fines. This aims to address the city's uniquely strict regulations, which have led to arrests of military personnel for minor infractions, and may face constitutional challenges regarding differential treatment of residents and non-residents.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Emily Miller on DC Gun Laws
  2. 00:30DC Council Reacts to Strict Gun Laws
  3. 00:36Cases of Military Arrests in DC
  4. 00:59Phil Mendelson's Proposed Bill
  5. 01:15D.C.'s Unique Registration Laws
  6. 02:08First Hearing on the New Bill
  7. 02:31Attorney General's Opposition
  8. 03:03Penalties for Non-Residents vs. Residents
  9. 03:14Bill's Potential Rewrites and Passage
  10. 04:00Constitutionality Questions Raised
  11. 04:36Dick Heller's Testimony and Perspective
  12. 04:55Ending Registration and Carry Bans
  13. 05:35Hope for Equal Constitutional Rights
  14. 06:04Comparison of D.C. Laws to Other Cities
  15. 06:33No Open or Concealed Carry in D.C.
  16. 06:44Future Carry Law Lawsuits and Supreme Court
  17. 07:02Scalia's Comments on Carry Laws
  18. 07:16Presidential Impact on Gun Rights
  19. 07:40D.C. as a Microcosm of National Issues
  20. 08:03Human Decency and Military Service

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the proposed change to Washington D.C.'s gun laws for non-residents?

A bill introduced in the DC Council aims to make it no longer a criminal offense for non-residents to unintentionally violate D.C.'s strict gun registration and ammunition possession laws. Instead, violations could result in an administrative fine rather than criminal charges.

Why are D.C.'s gun laws considered particularly strict?

D.C. is one of the few places requiring registration of every single firearm and ammunition. It also uniquely prohibits both open and concealed carry, leading to harsh penalties for even minor, unintentional infractions, especially for visitors.

What were the consequences of D.C.'s previous gun laws for military personnel?

Military members have been arrested and jailed in D.C. for seemingly innocent actions, such as legally transporting firearms through the city or forgetting ammunition in their bags, leading to criminal records for those who have served the country.

What is the potential constitutional issue with D.C.'s proposed law changes?

Legal experts and witnesses have raised concerns about the constitutionality of charging residents more severely than non-residents for committing the exact same firearm law violations, suggesting it may conflict with Article IV of the U.S. Constitution.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from NRA

View all →