Why the Supreme Court Keeps Rejecting Second Amendment Cases

This video discusses the US Supreme Court's denial of cert in two significant Second Amendment cases: Eva Gardner v. Maryland and George Peterson v. United States. While both cases were unfortunately turned down, the speaker, Mark Smith, a constitutional attorney and Second Amendment advocate, speculates on potential future positive outcomes. He suggests the court may be clearing the docket to focus on upcoming cases concerning AR-15 bans, magazine capacity limits, and the rights of young adults (18-20 years old).

The Supreme Court is considering seven major Second Amendment challenges, including four previously discussed cases (Duncan v. Bont, Gator v. Washington, Vera Montes v. Cook County, NGRV v. Lamont) and two new ones. Peterson v. United States challenges the NFA's taxation and registration scheme for firearms, particularly suppressors, arguing it violates the Second Amendment under the Bruen standard. Gardner v. Maryland addresses the Second Amendment rights of an interstate traveler carrying a handgun in self-defense when their out-of-state permit is not recognized by Maryland.

This video discusses Justice Clarence Thomas's speech identifying progressivism as a direct threat to the US Constitution. The speaker argues that progressive ideals attempt to circumvent constitutional protections, particularly regarding gun rights, citing the Heller and Bruen decisions as examples of the Supreme Court upholding individual rights against such attempts. The content emphasizes the significance of this judicial stance in defending fundamental freedoms.

This video from Washington Gun Law TV, hosted by William Kirk, analyzes why many believe the Supreme Court disregards Second Amendment rights. It examines the court's handling of cases like Wolford v. Lopez and Shenenthal v. Raul, focusing on how the court manages its caseload and the implications for Second Amendment jurisprudence. The discussion highlights the court's decisions on place and people restrictions, suggesting a pattern of rejecting cases that could clarify or strengthen gun rights.

The Supreme Court's decision to deny certiorari in Shoenthal v. Raul leaves in place a Seventh Circuit ruling upholding Illinois's ban on carrying firearms on public transportation. This ruling establishes public transit as a 'sensitive place' under the Bruen decision's framework, potentially paving the way for broader firearm restrictions nationwide. The speaker emphasizes the danger of this precedent, arguing it expands the 'sensitive places' doctrine beyond its intended scope and undermines the Second Amendment right to carry for self-defense.

The Duncan v. Bonta case, challenging California's magazine ban, is under Supreme Court consideration. A key argument for review, based on the US v. Benson ruling striking down a similar DC ban, has been undercut by the DC Court of Appeals granting an en banc rehearing in Benson. This shifts the legal landscape, potentially influencing the Supreme Court's decision to grant or deny certiorari for Duncan.

This entry details a significant lawsuit against Cabela's concerning ammunition sales and its potential ramifications for the entire firearms retail industry. The case, involving a fatal shooting by a 19-year-old, hinges on claims of negligence and exceptions to the Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act (PLCAA). Expert analysis suggests this could lead to broader liability for retailers if not dismissed.

This video, updated from a 2015 version, analyzes 2020 ATF registration data to rank US states by the number of registered NFA items. The speaker, an expert in 2A news, highlights that these figures represent legally owned items and are expected to grow. The analysis focuses on categories like Destructive Devices, Machineguns, Silencers, SBRs, SBSs, and AOWs, providing state-by-state breakdowns and concluding with commentary on gun owner rights.

This entry details the US Army's Modular Handgun System (MHS) contract decision, where the Sig Sauer P320 (M17/M18) was selected over Glock's submission. The analysis highlights key MHS requirements, the specific features of each submission, and crucially, the significant cost difference that heavily influenced the final decision. The Sig Sauer M17/M18 will replace the Beretta M9 in service.

This video from Guns & Gadgets discusses China's official stance that US citizens owning firearms is a serious problem requiring change. The host critically analyzes this statement, contrasting it with China's own human rights record and political system, while also referencing historical figures and current political figures like Senator Ben Sasse and Secretary of State Mike Pompeo. The content emphasizes the importance of the Second Amendment and warns against foreign influence on US gun policy.