Black Powder Revolvers for Daily Carry?

Published on November 10, 2024
Duration: 8:08

Dustin from Guns of the West argues against using cap and ball revolvers for everyday carry, citing their size, weight, low round count, and slower reloading capabilities compared to modern semi-automatic pistols like the Glock 17. He emphasizes that while historically significant and fun to shoot, their reliability issues and complex loading process make them impractical for self-defense scenarios. The video also touches on legal considerations for prohibited persons potentially carrying black powder firearms.

Quick Summary

Dustin from Guns of the West advises against using cap and ball revolvers for everyday carry. He highlights their impracticality due to size, weight, low round count, and slow reloading compared to modern semi-automatic pistols like the Glock 17, which offer better reliability and capacity for self-defense.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Cap and Ball for EDC?
  2. 00:28Short Answer: No
  3. 00:58The 1851 Navy London Reproduction
  4. 01:36Reasons Against EDC: Size and Weight
  5. 02:03Speaker's Daily Carry: Glock 17
  6. 02:27Reasons Against EDC: Round Count
  7. 02:42Reasons Against EDC: Reloading Capability
  8. 03:16Reasons Against EDC: Reliability
  9. 03:51Historical Context vs. Modern Reality
  10. 04:14Preference for Modern Firearms
  11. 04:23Single Action vs. Modern Action
  12. 04:50Legal Considerations for Prohibited Persons
  13. 05:50Speaker's EDC Gear: Holsters
  14. 07:02Conclusion: Recommend Modern Firearms
  15. 07:17Concealed Carry Class Promotion
  16. 07:34Final Thoughts on Controversial Subject

Frequently Asked Questions

Are cap and ball revolvers suitable for everyday carry?

No, according to Guns of the West host Dustin. While historically significant and fun to shoot, cap and ball revolvers are generally impractical for everyday carry due to their size, weight, low round count, and slow, complex reloading process compared to modern firearms.

What are the main disadvantages of using a cap and ball revolver for self-defense?

The primary disadvantages include their bulk and weight, limited capacity (5-6 rounds), the time-consuming process of reloading, and potential reliability issues like cap jams, which can be critical failures in a self-defense scenario.

What modern firearms does the speaker recommend for everyday carry?

The speaker, Dustin, personally carries modern semi-automatic pistols like the Glock 17 (9mm Luger, 17-round capacity), Glock 19, Glock 26, and has carried SIG Sauer pistols. He emphasizes their readiness and ease of use under stress.

Can prohibited persons legally carry cap and ball revolvers?

While cap and ball revolvers may have fewer regulations for purchase, they can still be classified as 'deadly weapons' or 'dangerous weapons' under federal law. Prohibited persons should be cautious, as carrying them may still violate laws restricting possession of such items.

More EDC & Lifestyle Videos You Might Like

More from Guns of the West

View all →