The Problems With 1911

Published on May 10, 2025
Duration: 11:15

This video explores the pros and cons of carrying a 1911 pistol for concealed carry, from a civilian perspective. While acknowledging its historical significance, stopping power in .45 ACP, and excellent trigger, the review highlights significant drawbacks for modern EDC. These include concealment challenges due to its full-size grip, discomfort from its weight and size during movement, and lower magazine capacity compared to many contemporary firearms. The presenter also discusses a reliability issue encountered around the 250-round mark and the higher cost of .45 ACP ammunition for training.

Quick Summary

The 1911 pistol offers advantages like a superior trigger for accuracy and strong stopping power with its .45 ACP caliber. However, for modern concealed carry, its full-size grip leads to concealment issues, its weight impacts comfort, and its magazine capacity is lower than many contemporary firearms. Reliability may also require diligent maintenance.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to the 1911
  2. 00:09Historical Context & Reputation
  3. 01:06Pros of Carrying a 1911
  4. 01:10Trigger Quality
  5. 01:31Accuracy Considerations
  6. 03:34Stopping Power (.45 ACP)
  7. 04:00Safety Mechanisms
  8. 05:06Cons of Carrying a 1911
  9. 05:08Concealment Challenges
  10. 05:34Carry Comfort & Movement Limitation
  11. 06:03Firearm Weight
  12. 06:21Recoil Discussion
  13. 07:08Magazine Capacity
  14. 08:03Reloading Speed
  15. 08:22Reliability Concerns
  16. 09:34Cost of Ammunition
  17. 09:58Conclusion: Would I Carry a 1911 Today?
  18. 10:35Final Thoughts & Alternatives

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main advantages of carrying a 1911 pistol?

The 1911 is renowned for its excellent trigger, offering a clean, linear pull that aids accuracy. It also boasts significant stopping power due to its .45 ACP chambering and features robust external safety mechanisms like the thumb and grip safeties, enhancing its perceived safety for carry.

What are the primary drawbacks of using a 1911 for concealed carry today?

Key drawbacks include its full-size dimensions, which make concealment difficult and can cause printing. The firearm's considerable weight can lead to discomfort during extended carry, and its standard magazine capacity is lower than many modern alternatives. The cost of .45 ACP ammunition also impacts training frequency.

Does the 1911 have reliability issues for concealed carry?

One reviewer experienced feeding issues around the 250-round mark, which were resolved after cleaning and lubrication. While this may have been an isolated incident, it raises questions about the 1911's reliability for concealed carry without diligent maintenance, especially compared to some other modern firearms.

How does the .45 ACP caliber affect the 1911's performance for self-defense?

The .45 ACP caliber is known for its stopping power, delivering a harder-hitting projectile due to its heavier bullet, even if it travels slower than 9mm. This makes it a popular choice for those prioritizing terminal ballistics in a self-defense firearm.

Related News

All News →

More EDC & Lifestyle Videos You Might Like

More from Shatterthewicked

View all →