Ask Ian - What Was the Best WW2 Rifle Cartridge?
Ian McCollum, a recognized expert in historical firearms from Forgotten Weapons, analyzes the optimal primary infantry rifle cartridge for World War II. He argues that while most nations used overpowered cartridges due to machine gun requirements, the 8x33mm Kurz was the most optimized for infantry rifles. McCollum also posits that the 7.35mm Carcano represented a superior balance for individual soldiers, and the US would have benefited from adopting a similar round for the M1 Garand.













