Forgotten Weapons Q&A November 2015

Published on November 6, 2015
Duration: 41:21

This Q&A session from Forgotten Weapons features Ian McCollum discussing various historical firearms and their development. Key topics include the dominance of Browning-style enclosed slides, the AR-15 as a superior modern rifle for WWI, the failure of turret revolvers due to chain fire, recommendations for affordable collectible firearms, and sources for rare parts. McCollum's deep expertise in firearms history and mechanics is evident throughout.

Quick Summary

Ian McCollum of Forgotten Weapons explains that the Browning-style enclosed slide became dominant over exposed barrel designs due to its manufacturing simplicity, lower cost, and enhanced reliability. He also identifies the AR-15 as the optimal modern rifle for a WWI soldier, citing its superior ergonomics and combat effectiveness.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and Patreon Support
  2. 00:45Exposed vs. Enclosed Slides
  3. 02:43Modern Firearms for WWI Soldiers
  4. 03:58Cochrane Turret Revolvers
  5. 06:45Affordable Collectible Firearms
  6. 10:58Wellrod Review Status
  7. 11:30Sources for C&R Parts

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did Browning-style enclosed slides become more popular than exposed barrel designs?

The Browning-style enclosed slide design gained dominance over exposed barrel designs like the Luger or P38 because it is simpler and cheaper to manufacture. It also offers improved reliability due to fewer external moving parts and easier machining processes.

What is the best modern rifle to give a WWI soldier?

According to Ian McCollum, the AR-15 is the best modern rifle to issue to a WWI soldier. Its balance of reliability, weight, accuracy, and shooter-friendly ergonomics makes it superior for practical combat effectiveness compared to WWI-era firearms.

Why were turret revolvers unsuccessful?

Turret revolvers, despite their mechanical design, largely failed due to the significant risk of 'chain fire.' This dangerous malfunction involves the simultaneous ignition of multiple chambers, potentially firing rounds directly at the shooter's face and hands.

What are some affordable collectible firearms?

Affordable collectible firearms often found between $200-$400 include the Indonesian Mannlicher M95 (especially in .303 British), Star 28/30/31 pistols, Daewoo DP51, and various Italian or French military revolvers.

Related News

All News →

More General Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →