Q&A - Part 1

Published on April 4, 2023
Duration: 185:30

This Q&A session from C&Rsenal covers a wide range of firearms topics, from the surprising complexity of repeating shotguns and the Pedersen device to the nuances of Mauser actions and the historical significance of various revolvers. The hosts discuss the engineering challenges behind firearms like the Winchester 97, the evolution of pistol actions, and the aesthetic appeal of different rifle designs. They also touch upon the practicalities of concealed carry, the challenges of historical firearms research, and the enduring legacy of certain firearm designs.

Quick Summary

The Mauser 98 action is preferred for military applications over the Schlegelmilch action due to its superior handling of case failures and overcharged ammunition. Its robust design offers better cartridge rim support and enhanced gas mitigation, providing greater security of strength in demanding combat conditions.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to the Q&A
  2. 01:57Most Surprising Gun Related Thing
  3. 04:05Webley Revolver Cylinder Stop Mechanism
  4. 05:55Mauser 98 vs. Schlegelmilch Action
  5. 07:21Popularity of the Gahendra Rifle
  6. 10:01Significance of the Remington New Model Army
  7. 12:27Star Model 1921 08 Conversion
  8. 13:02Firearms Defying Expectations
  9. 16:07Borchardt C93 Pistol Plans
  10. 17:08Reluctant Firearm Episodes
  11. 20:09Aircraft MGs Converted to Infantry Use
  12. 22:03British vs. American Rifle Workmanship
  13. 25:34Orkis Pistol for Concealed Carry
  14. 26:53Swedish M96 Mauser Trigger Modification
  15. 28:14Colt 1873 Single Action Army Innovation
  16. 32:55Bond Arms Lever Gun with AR-15 Mags
  17. 35:20Colt New Service Internals
  18. 37:46Favorite Full Powered Rifle Cartridge
  19. 40:13Non-Rotating Bolt Head Primary Extraction
  20. 42:34Smith & Wesson vs. Kel-Tec Sub-2000
  21. 48:46Grail Guns
  22. 50:59Most Innovative Firearm Action
  23. 54:51Best Central Powers WWI Bolt Action Rifle
  24. 56:43Inventor of Steel Case Ammunition
  25. 57:17Best WWI Rifle for Trench Warfare
  26. 59:41Firearms with Interesting Histories
  27. 61:00Dominance of Tilting Barrel Pistol System
  28. 62:30Aesthetically Pleasing Gun Aspects

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the most surprising firearm feature or experience discussed by C&Rsenal?

The most surprising firearm feature discussed was the complexity of repeating shotguns and the Pedersen device. The Pedersen device, despite its appearance, can lead to self-destruction due to a lack of design tolerance. Repeating shotguns, especially for larger cartridges, are surprisingly intricate due to the engineering needed for cartridge handling and safety.

Why is the Mauser 98 action preferred over the Schlegelmilch action for military use?

The Mauser 98 action is preferred for military applications due to its superior ability to handle case failures and overcharged ammunition. Its robust design provides better support for the cartridge rim and enhanced gas mitigation, offering greater security of strength in demanding combat conditions.

What makes the Gahendra rifle popular, and what are its drawbacks?

The Gahendra rifle's popularity stems primarily from its low cost, as they were imported from Nepal and are often in rough condition. Drawbacks include questions about its metallurgy and safety when using standard .450 Martini ammunition, making it a less reliable firearm.

What is the significance of the Remington New Model Army revolver?

The Remington New Model Army revolver is noted for featuring a top strap, an improvement over some contemporary Colt designs. However, it had zero evolutionary significance in the broader firearms world, meaning it did not contribute to the advancement of firearm technology or design.

Why is the Colt Single Action Army (1873) considered lacking in innovation?

The Colt Single Action Army (1873) is criticized for its limited innovation, largely reusing the lockwork from earlier models. Its primary improvements were the addition of a top strap and a roller on the mainspring, which are considered minor advancements rather than significant design breakthroughs.

More General Videos You Might Like

More from C&Rsenal

View all →