Practical Pistol Show 212

Published on September 14, 2017
Duration: 34:29

This video features a discussion among competitive shooters about the Area 3 match, highlighting its unique stage designs, which are often described as 'gimmicky' or 'carnival-like.' The participants express mixed opinions, with some appreciating the innovative challenges while others raise significant concerns about safety, practicality, and the number of disqualifications (DQs) resulting from these unconventional stages. The conversation delves into specific examples of stages that were problematic, particularly for left-handed shooters or those with physical limitations, and contrasts them with more traditional match formats.

Quick Summary

Competitive shooters discuss the Area 3 match, noting its 'gimmicky' stages, safety concerns, and high DQ rate. While some appreciate the innovation, others criticize the impracticality and potential risks, such as stages with pool noodles or tractor tires, and issues with vague 180-degree lines.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & Banter
  2. 01:11Discussion on Area 3 Match
  3. 02:13Area 3 Stage Design Philosophy
  4. 03:17Carnival Game / Gimmick Stages
  5. 05:00Specific Gimmick Stage Examples
  6. 05:33Safety Concerns: Pool Noodle Stage
  7. 07:07Problematic Stage for Left-Handed Shooters
  8. 09:44Overall Match Impressions
  9. 10:24Dangerous Stage Incidents
  10. 11:38Disqualifications (DQs) at Area 3
  11. 12:25Vague 180 Lines and RO Issues
  12. 13:53Roof Stage Incident
  13. 14:25Characterization of Area 3
  14. 14:47Decision Not to Return
  15. 15:05Match Quality vs. Major Competitions
  16. 15:46Moving Target Stage Criticism
  17. 16:02Mixed Feelings on Gimmicks
  18. 16:23Barbell Stage Analysis
  19. 18:26Tim's Take on Interesting Stages
  20. 19:21Finding the Line Between Interesting and Gimmicky
  21. 20:46Appreciation for Innovation vs. Safety
  22. 21:1885% Hosing vs. 15% Challenging
  23. 21:43Would You Go Back?
  24. 22:05Lessons Learned
  25. 22:39Enjoyment of Shooting Challenges
  26. 23:08Specific Liked Stages
  27. 24:12Drop Turner Stage Discussion
  28. 25:01Area 3 Target Philosophy
  29. 26:29End of Area 3 Discussion
  30. 26:31Transition to Listener Question
  31. 27:26Listener Question: Limited Range Practice
  32. 29:11Advice for Limited Range Practice
  33. 32:42Closing Remarks & Thank You
  34. 32:54Submit Your Questions
  35. 33:10GoFundMe for Match Critique
  36. 33:25Tim's Match Critique Persona
  37. 34:07Movie Recommendation

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main criticisms of the Area 3 match?

The primary criticisms of the Area 3 match revolve around its 'gimmicky' or 'carnival-like' stage designs, which some shooters find impractical and potentially unsafe. Concerns include stages that lead to excessive time, high numbers of disqualifications (DQs), and designs that may not be equitable for all shooters, particularly left-handed individuals.

What makes Area 3 stages different from typical competition stages?

Area 3 stages often incorporate unique elements like manual target reactivation, obstacles such as pool noodles, and physical challenges like jumping over tires or carrying barbells. While some appreciate the innovation, many find these 'gimmicks' detract from the core shooting skills and can introduce unnecessary safety risks or logistical complexities.

Were there significant safety concerns raised about the Area 3 match?

Yes, safety was a major concern. Specific stages, like the one with pool noodles designed to obstruct movement, were criticized for potentially causing shooters to lose eye or ear protection. Another stage involving tractor tires led to an injury and a firearm going 180 degrees, highlighting the risks associated with unconventional stage design.

How did the shooters feel about the number of DQs at Area 3?

The participants noted a high number of disqualifications (DQs) at the Area 3 match, with some suggesting it had doubled from the previous year. This was attributed to the complex and sometimes ambiguous stage designs, as well as potential issues with RO interpretation of rules on these unconventional stages.

Related News

All News →

More Range & Competition Videos You Might Like

More from Ben Stoeger

View all →