WALTHER Q5-SF VS.4.5" PDP-SF | Going Gone...

Published on October 8, 2024
Duration: 5:47

This video compares the Walther Q5 SF and the Walther PDP SF (4.5-inch steel frame), detailing the speaker's preference for the PDP SF due to its less 'bouncy' recoil and better balance. The speaker discusses aftermarket modifications, including an OverWatch Precision trigger and IMBEL/Lock grips, which were crucial for resolving trigger reach issues on the PDP SF. Ultimately, the Q5 SF is retired from the speaker's safe in favor of the PDP SF.

Quick Summary

The Walther PDP SF (4.5-inch steel frame) is preferred over the Q5 SF due to its less 'bouncy' recoil and better balance. While the PDP SF presented trigger reach issues, these were resolved with an OverWatch Precision trigger and IMBEL/Lock grips, making it the speaker's primary competition handgun.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to Walther Pistols
  2. 00:08Q5 SF vs. PDP SF Comparison
  3. 00:16Speaker's Competition Journey
  4. 01:00Pricing and Availability
  5. 01:12Walther Q5 SF Details
  6. 01:52Q5 SF Recoil Characteristics
  7. 02:13Recoil Spring Experimentation
  8. 02:38Introducing the Walther PDP SF
  9. 03:06PDP SF Initial Impressions
  10. 03:27PDP SF Trigger Reach Issues
  11. 03:49Aftermarket Modifications (Trigger & Grips)
  12. 04:04Trigger Reach Solution
  13. 04:11IMBEL/Lock Grip Review
  14. 04:40The Decision: Which Gun Leaves?
  15. 05:00Final Thoughts and Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between the Walther Q5 SF and the Walther PDP SF?

The primary difference highlighted is recoil impulse; the PDP SF is described as noticeably less 'bouncy' than the Q5 SF. The PDP SF also presented trigger reach issues for the speaker, which were resolved with aftermarket parts, while the Q5 SF's grip size was manageable with modifications.

What aftermarket modifications were discussed for the Walther PDP SF?

The speaker installed an OverWatch Precision trigger to address trigger reach issues and IMBEL/Lock grips to improve ergonomics and reduce the front-to-back grip distance on their Walther PDP SF.

Why is the Walther Q5 SF being retired from the speaker's safe?

The Walther Q5 SF is being retired because the speaker now strongly prefers the Walther PDP SF (4.5-inch steel frame) due to its more balanced feel and less 'bouncy' recoil, leading to the Q5 SF not seeing much range time.

What issues did the speaker encounter with the Walther Q5 SF's recoil system?

The speaker found the Q5 SF's recoil to be 'bouncy' and experimented with aftermarket recoil springs. However, non-factory springs often resulted in light strikes and failures to go into battery, leading them to revert to the factory spring.

More Range & Competition Videos You Might Like

More from Tessah Booth

View all →