2 Best Compact Handguns For 2025? | USCCA Gun Reviews

Published on April 17, 2025
Duration: 15:48

This review compares the Walther PDP and the Smith & Wesson M&P Carry Comp 2.0, two compact 9mm handguns. The Walther PDP is praised for its reliability, durability, and accuracy, especially considering its lower price point. The S&W M&P Carry Comp 2.0 stands out with its Performance Center trigger, included cleaning kit, and magazine extensions, offering excellent out-of-the-box accuracy with iron sights.

Quick Summary

The Walther PDP is praised for its extreme condition reliability and value at around $550, while the S&W M&P Carry Comp 2.0 ($750) offers a superior Performance Center trigger, included cleaning kit, and excellent iron sight accuracy. Both are compact 9mm handguns with comparable widths.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Compact Handgun Review
  2. 00:07Walther PDP Overview
  3. 00:17Smith & Wesson M&P Carry Comp 2.0 Overview
  4. 00:22Firearm Sponsorship: Guns GDC
  5. 00:39Smith & Wesson M&P Carry Comp 2.0 Unboxing
  6. 01:35S&W M&P Screw and Plate Kit
  7. 01:52S&W M&P Magazines and Backstraps
  8. 02:24S&W M&P Magazine Extensions
  9. 02:59Walther PDP Unboxing
  10. 03:41Walther PDP Performance & Testing
  11. 04:06Walther PDP Ergonomics and Controls
  12. 04:44Walther PDP Slide Serrations & Ease of Use
  13. 05:02Walther PDP Torture Testing Results
  14. 05:32Walther PDP Durability Issue: Front Sight
  15. 05:42Walther PDP Standard vs. Pro Model
  16. 05:58Walther PDP Optics Ready & Sights
  17. 06:01Walther PDP Magazine Release
  18. 06:24Walther PDP Ammunition Testing
  19. 07:03Walther PDP Accuracy at Distance
  20. 07:23Smith & Wesson M&P Carry Comp 2.0 Performance
  21. 07:37Compensated Pistols Comparison
  22. 07:55S&W M&P Carry Comp 2.0 Ammunition Testing
  23. 09:00S&W M&P Carry Comp 2.0 Accuracy with Iron Sights
  24. 09:23S&W M&P Carry Comp 2.0 Iron Sights
  25. 09:31S&W M&P Compensated Barrel Feature
  26. 09:44S&W M&P Slide Serrations
  27. 09:57S&W M&P Ambi Controls
  28. 10:02S&W M&P Performance Center Trigger
  29. 10:24S&W M&P Ergonomics and Backstraps
  30. 10:34S&W M&P Dovetail Length for Carry
  31. 10:44S&W M&P Modularity and Value
  32. 11:13Walther PDP Technical Specifications
  33. 11:16Walther PDP Caliber and Dimensions
  34. 11:37Walther PDP Barrel Length and Sight Radius
  35. 11:45Walther PDP Weight and Trigger Pull
  36. 12:08Smith & Wesson M&P Carry Comp 2.0 Tech Specs
  37. 12:10S&W M&P Barrel Length and Compensator
  38. 12:19S&W M&P Sight Radius and Weight
  39. 12:32S&W M&P Overall Length and Height
  40. 12:46Trigger Pull Measurement: S&W M&P
  41. 13:27Trigger Pull Measurement: Walther PDP
  42. 13:46Trigger Comparison: Duty Grade
  43. 14:06Walther PDP Trigger vs. Shooter Comfort
  44. 14:18S&W M&P Trigger vs. Shooter Speed
  45. 14:45Upcoming: 1000 Round Review & Battle Royale
  46. 14:58Firearm Sponsorship Acknowledgment
  47. 15:04Viewer Suggestions for Future Reviews
  48. 15:23USCCA Concealed Carry Map Resource
  49. 15:40Conclusion and Sign-off

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the Walther PDP and the Smith & Wesson M&P Carry Comp 2.0?

The Walther PDP excels in extreme condition reliability and offers great value at around $550. The S&W M&P Carry Comp 2.0, at about $750, features a superior Performance Center trigger, includes a cleaning kit and magazine extensions, and boasts excellent out-of-the-box iron sight accuracy.

How do the triggers of the Walther PDP and S&W M&P Carry Comp 2.0 compare?

The Walther PDP has a measured trigger pull averaging 4.98 lbs, described as clean with minimal creep. The S&W M&P Carry Comp 2.0's Performance Center trigger is lighter, averaging 3.93 lbs, and is noted for its smoothness, repeatability, and clean break, making it a standout feature.

Which compact handgun is more durable in harsh conditions: the Walther PDP or the S&W M&P Carry Comp 2.0?

The Walther PDP demonstrated superior durability in torture testing, functioning flawlessly after exposure to silt, water, sand, and mud. While the S&W M&P Carry Comp 2.0 is also robust, the PDP's performance in extreme conditions was highlighted as exceptional.

What accessories are included with the Smith & Wesson M&P Carry Comp 2.0?

The S&W M&P Carry Comp 2.0 comes with a chamber lock, user manual, safe sticker, a cleaning kit with brushes and a pick, a screw and plate kit for red dot mounting, two 15-round flush-fit magazines, four interchangeable backstraps, and magazine extension plates.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from USCCA

View all →