AR-15 Silver Bullet Shootout!....Winchester Silvertip vs Liberty Ammo Civil Defense!

Published on May 26, 2023
Duration: 14:57

This video provides a detailed comparison of Winchester Silvertip 64gr and Liberty Ammunition Civil Defense 55gr rounds fired from an AR-15. The instructor conducts ballistic testing using a gel setup and Labradar chronograph, measuring velocity, penetration, and projectile performance after passing through a heavy clothing barrier. Both rounds demonstrated effective fragmentation and terminal ballistics, making them suitable for defensive purposes.

Quick Summary

In an AR-15 gel test, the Winchester Silvertip 64gr .223 round averaged 2805 ft/s and penetrated approximately 13.75 inches after extensive fragmentation. The Liberty Civil Defense 55gr .223 round averaged 2929 ft/s, fragmented heavily, and penetrated about 19.2 inches. Both are considered excellent defensive rounds.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and Setup
  2. 00:44Ammunition Overview: Winchester Silvertip vs. Liberty Civil Defense
  3. 01:36Firearm Platform: AR-15 16-inch Barrel
  4. 01:59Liberty Ammo Civil Defense Velocity Test
  5. 03:43Winchester Silvertip Velocity Test
  6. 05:34Silver Bullet Gel Test: Civil Defense vs. Silvertip
  7. 07:03Gel Test Results: Top View Analysis
  8. 09:08Penetration and Shrapnel Analysis
  9. 10:36Projectile Examination: Post-Test Analysis
  10. 11:22Weight Retention and Size Measurements
  11. 12:18Conclusion: Silvertip vs. Civil Defense Performance

Frequently Asked Questions

How did the Winchester Silvertip 64gr .223 perform in gel testing?

The Winchester Silvertip 64gr .223 round showed excellent expansion and fragmentation in gel tests, penetrating approximately 13.75 inches. It retained 43.6 grains of its original 64-grain weight, demonstrating good terminal ballistics after passing through a heavy clothing barrier.

What were the results of the Liberty Ammunition Civil Defense 55gr .223 gel test?

The Liberty Ammunition Civil Defense 55gr .223 round fragmented extensively, creating numerous copper pieces and a central core that penetrated about 19.2 inches. It retained 23.2 grains of its original 55-grain weight, indicating a high degree of energy dump and fragmentation.

Which .223/5.56 defensive round is better: Winchester Silvertip or Liberty Civil Defense?

Both rounds performed exceptionally well in this AR-15 gel test. The Silvertip retained more weight, while the Civil Defense fragmented more. The instructor considered it a tough decision, suggesting both are highly effective for defensive purposes and the choice may come down to personal preference.

What were the measured velocities for the tested .223/5.56 ammunition?

The Winchester Silvertip 64gr averaged 2805 ft/s from a 16-inch barrel, exceeding its advertised velocity. The Liberty Civil Defense 55gr averaged 2929 ft/s at the muzzle, slightly below its advertised 3000 ft/s. Velocities were measured at the muzzle and at 30 yards.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Tools&Targets

View all →