Berthier with a Chauchat Magazine at the Range

Published on June 13, 2020
Duration: 7:21

This custom Berthier rifle conversion, designed to accept an 18-round Chauchat magazine, proved mechanically unreliable during range testing. The heavily tapered 8mm Lebel cartridge is fundamentally unsuitable for box magazines, leading to feeding failures and magazine detachment due to recoil. While historically interesting as a survival rifle concept, the conversion is not practical for reliable use.

Quick Summary

The Berthier rifle converted to use an 18-round Chauchat magazine proved unreliable due to the 8mm Lebel cartridge's design. Its tapered, rimmed nature caused feeding jams, and recoil often detached the magazine, making it impractical despite its historical survival rifle concept.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Berthier Chauchat Mag Conversion
  2. 01:00Loading 8mm Lebel & Model History
  3. 02:50Chauchat Magazine Mechanism Explained
  4. 03:21Range Test: Initial Failures & Recoil
  5. 04:20Malfunction Analysis: Cartridge Feed Issues
  6. 05:58Conclusion: 8mm Lebel Unsuitability for Box Mags

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the historical significance of the Berthier rifle with a Chauchat magazine?

This modification aimed to create a higher-capacity survival rifle, potentially for French Air Force use during WWI, offering 18 rounds instead of the standard three. It represents an interesting, though mechanically flawed, historical experiment.

Why did the Berthier rifle with the Chauchat magazine fail during testing?

The heavily tapered and rimmed 8mm Lebel cartridge is unsuitable for box magazines. Recoil caused cartridges to shift and jam, while the magazine itself tended to detach due to the stress of firing.

What are the main mechanical issues with using 8mm Lebel in a box magazine?

The cartridge's rimmed and tapered design leads to rim overlap and feeding failures. Additionally, the magazine's floorplate locking system proved susceptible to detachment under recoil, further compromising reliability.

Who built the custom Berthier rifle with the Chauchat magazine?

The custom build featured in the video was created by Mark Novak of Anvil Gunsmithing. Ian McCollum of Forgotten Weapons conducted the range testing and analysis.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →