Colt vs. Uberti: 1849 Pocket Model

Published on May 23, 2022
Duration: 9:15

This video compares an original Colt 1849 Pocket Model revolver (1858 manufacture) with a modern Uberti reproduction. The hosts detail numerous cosmetic and functional differences, including front sight size, barrel length variations, loading port taper, cylinder engraving, serial number placement, recoil shield rise, hammer spring stiffness, grip thickness, and muzzle crowning. While acknowledging the unique appeal of an original, the video concludes that Uberti provides a well-made, affordable reproduction that captures the historical feel of the Colt 1849 Pocket Model.

Quick Summary

The Uberti 1849 Pocket Model reproduction offers a more visible front sight and a better-crowned muzzle than the original Colt, while both accommodate conical bullets well. However, the Colt features more extensive serialization and a stiffer hammer spring, highlighting key differences in manufacturing and design between the historical firearm and its modern replica.

Chapters

  1. 00:33Colt 1849 Pocket Close-up
  2. 00:44Uberti 1849 Pocket Close-up
  3. 01:09Front Sight Comparison
  4. 01:34Barrel Length Variation
  5. 01:48Loading Lever Latches
  6. 01:57Wedge Comparison
  7. 02:02Disassembly - Wedge and Cylinder
  8. 02:18Arbor Grooves
  9. 02:33Recoil Shield Comparison
  10. 02:44Loading Ports
  11. 03:06Barrel Markings
  12. 03:13Loading Lever Operation
  13. 03:26Cylinder Engraving
  14. 03:37Cylinder Markings
  15. 03:44Serialization Comparison
  16. 04:18Hammer Spring Discussion
  17. 05:08Hammer Knurling
  18. 05:15Frame Material (Brass/Silver)
  19. 05:25Grip Thickness
  20. 05:46Cleaning Pins
  21. 06:08Loading Lever Grip Texture
  22. 06:27Loading Lever Operation Difficulty
  23. 06:41Muzzle Crown Comparison
  24. 07:03Rifling Comparison
  25. 07:23Plunger Recess for Conicals
  26. 07:55Chamber Edge Rounding
  27. 08:13Loading Lever Screw
  28. 08:24Overall Uberti Reproduction Quality
  29. 08:47Conclusion: Original vs Reproduction

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between an original Colt 1849 Pocket Model and a Uberti reproduction?

Key differences include the Uberti's larger front sight, potential barrel length variations, a sharp vs. tapered loading port cut, extensive serialization on the Colt versus limited serialization on the Uberti, and differences in hammer spring stiffness and muzzle crowning. The Uberti also features a more textured loading lever grip.

How does the hammer spring compare between the Colt 1849 Pocket and its Uberti reproduction?

The original Colt 1849 Pocket Model has a much thicker and stiffer hammer spring, which can make cocking difficult and even painful without modification. Uberti reproductions typically have lighter springs, which can sometimes lead to cap jams, prompting some owners to add a second spring for increased tension.

Are Uberti reproductions accurate copies of the Colt 1849 Pocket Model?

Uberti is generally considered to have done a good job of copying the Colt 1849 Pocket Model, especially in terms of functionality like the plunger recess for conical bullets. While there are cosmetic and minor functional differences, they provide an affordable way to experience a historical firearm.

What are the advantages of the Uberti 1849 Pocket Model's loading port and muzzle?

The Uberti 1849 Pocket Model features a sharp cut loading port, which functions well for various projectiles. Its muzzle is nicely beveled with a crown, offering a more finished and aesthetically pleasing appearance compared to the rougher, saw-cut look of the original Colt's muzzle.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Guns of the West

View all →