Hornady Critical Defense Review

Published on July 29, 2015
Duration: 1:59

This review tests Hornady Critical Defense ammunition in two Walther pistols: a short-barreled PPS and a duty-length P99AS. The ammunition demonstrated reliable feeding and cycling in both firearms, with good grouping. A penetration test using FBI 10 blocks and an interior wall showed the round penetrated the first block and wall, stopping within the second block, suggesting it would likely stop within a human target and not over-penetrate into a subsequent room.

Quick Summary

Hornady Critical Defense ammunition demonstrated reliable feeding and cycling in both a Walther PPS and P99AS. In a penetration test, the rounds went through an FBI 10 block and interior wall, stopping within the second block, suggesting a reduced risk of over-penetration in self-defense scenarios.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to Hornady Critical Defense
  2. 00:12Testing in Walther PPS
  3. 00:39Testing in Walther P99AS
  4. 01:01Penetration Test Setup
  5. 01:24Penetration Test Results
  6. 01:31Analysis of Penetration
  7. 01:42Conclusion on Hornady Reputation

Frequently Asked Questions

How did Hornady Critical Defense ammunition perform in the Walther PPS?

In the short-barreled Walther PPS, Hornady Critical Defense ammunition experienced no cycling issues and demonstrated good grouping, indicating reliable performance in this compact handgun.

What were the results of the ballistic penetration test for Hornady Critical Defense?

The test involved an FBI 10 block, an interior wall, and a second FBI 10 block. The Critical Defense round successfully penetrated the first block and wall, stopping about 1.5 inches into the second block.

Is Hornady Critical Defense ammunition considered reliable for self-defense?

Based on the testing, Hornady Critical Defense ammunition proved to be reliable in both feeding and cycling in different Walther pistol models. The penetration test also suggests it performs as expected for self-defense, with a tendency to stop within a target.

What is the perceived risk of over-penetration with Hornady Critical Defense?

The reviewer believes that the Critical Defense round would likely stop within a human target, minimizing the risk of over-penetration into a subsequent room, as demonstrated by its performance in the ballistic test.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from GBGuns

View all →