Cache.Deals

M&P LE Trade Ins | Worth It?

The Gun Dungeon
Published on March 15, 2025
Category: Reviews
Duration: 14:22

This video reviews Smith & Wesson M&P police trade-in firearms, focusing on first-generation models. The presenter highlights key differences from standard civilian models, including a heavier trigger pull often referred to as a 'New York Trigger' and a mandatory magazine disconnect feature. Despite these characteristics, the firearms are deemed a good value due to their low price point, proven reliability, and often included night sights, with finish wear being generally acceptable for their intended purpose.

Tags

M&P 40
M&P 45C
M&P Subcompact
Police Trade-In
First Gen M&P
Magazine Disconnect
New York Trigger
Night Sights
Used Firearms
Value Firearms

Quick Summary

M&P police trade-in firearms, especially first-generation models, often feature a heavier trigger pull ('New York Trigger') and a magazine disconnect, unlike standard civilian versions. While triggers may not be top-tier, they are usable, and these firearms offer excellent value with features like night sights and moderate finish wear.

Chapters

  1. 00:43Introduction to M&P Police Trade-Ins
  2. 01:08Comparing Full Size and Sub Compact M&P Models
  3. 01:48First Gen M&P Trigger Reputation
  4. 02:36Trigger Differences: Trade-In vs. Standard
  5. 03:01Full Size Trade-In Trigger Pull
  6. 03:26Sub Compact Trade-In Trigger Issues
  7. 04:14Magazine Disconnect Feature Explained
  8. 04:56Slide Markings: Trade-In vs. Civilian
  9. 05:30Prevalence of Magazine Disconnect on Trade-Ins
  10. 06:04Slide Removal Without Trigger Pull
  11. 06:36Potential Pains of Magazine Disconnect
  12. 06:43Reliability and Round Count of Trade-Ins
  13. 07:04Finish Wear on M&P Trade-Ins
  14. 07:15Close-up of Finish Wear Examples
  15. 08:17Value Proposition of M&P Trade-Ins
  16. 08:33Shooting Impressions and Reliability
  17. 09:23Trigger Quality: Good vs. Bad
  18. 09:46Standard M&P Features and Law Enforcement Requirements
  19. 10:00Heavier Trigger (New York Trigger)
  20. 10:11Value and Price of Trade-In M&Ps
  21. 10:17Night Sights on Trade-In Models
  22. 11:02Favorite Gun to Shoot: M&P 45C
  23. 11:18Ideal Use Case: Everyday Carry
  24. 11:30Aftermarket Support for M&P
  25. 11:41Best Price for Value
  26. 11:53Don't Fear the Trigger
  27. 12:11Purpose of Heavier Triggers
  28. 12:30Trigger Usability vs. Best-in-Class
  29. 13:08Grading Systems for Used Firearms
  30. 13:16Conclusion: M&P Police Trade-Ins are Good Value
  31. 13:19Caliber Trends: 40 S&W vs. 9mm
  32. 13:30Jump on .40 Cal Trade-Ins Now
  33. 13:57Outro and Call to Action

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between M&P police trade-in firearms and standard civilian models?

M&P police trade-in firearms, particularly first-generation models, often feature a heavier trigger pull, sometimes called a 'New York Trigger,' and a mandatory magazine disconnect that prevents firing without a magazine inserted. These features are typically not present on standard civilian versions.

Are the triggers on M&P police trade-in firearms good?

First-generation M&P triggers were not known for being great, and police trade-ins often have an even heavier pull. While they can smooth out over time and are usable, they are generally not as good as the triggers found on newer M&P 2.0 models.

Do M&P police trade-in firearms come with night sights?

Yes, many M&P police trade-in firearms come equipped with night sights. However, the effectiveness and brightness of these sights will depend on their age and how long they have been in use.

What is the typical condition of M&P police trade-in firearms?

The finish wear on M&P police trade-ins is generally moderate, with wear often seen on the top of the slide and muzzle from holster use. Many are described as having been carried a lot but shot relatively little, making them a good value.

Are M&P police trade-in firearms a good value for the money?

Yes, M&P police trade-in firearms are generally considered a very good value. They offer a proven platform with a lot of gun for a low price, often including features like night sights, making them an attractive option for budget-conscious buyers.

Related Articles

All Articles →
The Rifle America Keeps Banning: 50 Years of AK-47 Import Restrictions
Explainer20 min read

The Rifle America Keeps Banning: 50 Years of AK-47 Import Restrictions

Canik MC9 Prime: Complete Guide
Gear Deep Dive18 min read

Canik MC9 Prime: Complete Guide

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

Smith and Wesson M&P 40 or Stoeger STR9 - which would you buy and why? #shorts #Stoeger #STR9 #S&W
Smith and Wesson M&P 40 or Stoeger STR9 - which would you buy and why? #shorts #Stoeger #STR9 #S&W

This YouTube Shorts video compares the Smith & Wesson M&P 40 and the Stoeger STR9, asking viewers which they would purchase for $275 or less, highlighting reliability and value. The content focuses on a direct comparison of two popular handguns in a budget-conscious segment of the firearms market.

Smith & Wesson
M&P 40
Channel:Cranky Gun Reviews
Category:Reviews
Date: Jun 27, 2024
Duration: 0:52

More from The Gun Dungeon

View all →
Ruger 10/22 vs Marlin Model 60: Head to Head accuracy test.
Ruger 10/22 vs Marlin Model 60: Head to Head accuracy test.

This video provides a head-to-head accuracy test between the Ruger 10/22 and the Marlin Model 60, both chambered in .22 LR. The host, an experienced shooter, details the test methodology, including ammunition types and a consistent 25-yard range. The comparison highlights key features of each rifle, such as magazine capacity and aftermarket availability, concluding with a visual presentation of the shot groups.

Ruger 10/22
Marlin Model 60
Channel:The Gun Dungeon
Category:Reviews
Date: Aug 21, 2021
Duration: 15:51
38 special snub ballistics gel test
38 special snub ballistics gel test

This video details a comprehensive ballistics gel test for various .38 Special loads fired from a Smith & Wesson 642 snub-nose revolver. The expert instructor analyzes bullet expansion, penetration, and wound channels, offering critical insights into ammunition performance for self-defense. Key takeaways include the importance of bullet design for reliable expansion in short barrels and safety considerations for handloading .38 Special ammunition.

.38 Special
Smith & Wesson 642
Channel:The Gun Dungeon
Category:Tactical & Gear
Date: Dec 18, 2020
Duration: 14:23
9mm vs 40 S&W ballistic gel: Head to Head!
9mm vs 40 S&W ballistic gel: Head to Head!

This guide details a head-to-head ballistic gel test comparing 9mm Luger +P and .40 S&W ammunition, as demonstrated by an experienced firearms reviewer. The test involved firing specific loads through denim barriers into gel blocks, measuring velocity and penetration, and analyzing recovered projectiles. The .40 S&W HST showed more dramatic expansion, while the 9mm +P achieved deeper penetration. The comparison highlights trade-offs between terminal performance, capacity, and recoil in compact firearms.

9mm Luger
40 S&W
Channel:The Gun Dungeon
Category:Tactical & Gear
Date: Jun 19, 2021
Duration: 9:39
50 beowulf: First Shots!
50 beowulf: First Shots!

This video demonstrates the initial live fire of a .50 Beowulf AR-15 platform rifle, featuring a side-charging upper receiver and a Vortex red dot optic. The host, identified as a firearms enthusiast and content creator, showcases the loading process, firing, and the significant impact of the large caliber rounds on steel targets at an outdoor range. The demonstration highlights proficient firearm handling and range safety awareness.

.50 Beowulf
AR-15
Channel:The Gun Dungeon
Category:Tactical & Gear
Date: Feb 26, 2022
Duration: 0:16
Find an FFL
Licensed dealers in your area