Movie Review: 1917

Published on March 5, 2020
Duration: 11:46

This review of the WWI film '1917' by Forgotten Weapons highlights its strong realism in depicting battlefield elements like barbed wire and trench systems, contrasting British and German fortifications. While praising the cinematography, the reviewer notes the 'one continuous shot' technique can compress distances unrealistically. Minor technical inaccuracies are present but don't detract significantly from the narrative's effectiveness.

Quick Summary

The WWI film '1917' is praised for its realistic depiction of barbed wire and contrasting trench systems between British and German forces. While the continuous shot technique is noted for compressing distances unrealistically, minor technical inaccuracies don't detract from its effectiveness.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: 1917 Movie Review
  2. 00:48Battlefield Realism: Barbed Wire Depiction
  3. 03:13Trench Systems: British vs. German
  4. 05:37Cinematography: Continuous Shot Technique
  5. 08:46Technical Accuracy & Plot Plausibility

Frequently Asked Questions

How realistic is the depiction of barbed wire in the movie '1917'?

The review highlights the film's excellent and realistic portrayal of WWI barbed wire, describing it as a 'rat's nest' of rusty, mud-encrusted wire. This detail is noted as often missing from historical photographs due to the dangers faced by photographers.

What are the key differences between British and German trenches shown in '1917'?

The film depicts German trenches as more permanent and structurally sound, reflecting their defensive strategy. In contrast, British trenches are shown as more temporary, aligning with their different approach to fortification during WWI.

Does the 'one continuous shot' technique in '1917' affect its realism?

While technically impressive, the reviewer suggests the continuous shot technique compresses distances unrealistically. Locations that should be miles apart appear reachable in minutes, potentially breaking immersion for viewers familiar with the geography.

Are there significant historical inaccuracies in the movie '1917'?

Minor technical issues like gas mask placement are mentioned but deemed insignificant. The plot's reliance on runners, while less efficient than aircraft historically, is accepted as a necessary narrative device for the film's story.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →