Smyth Busters: Are Old Smith & Wessons Better Than New Ones?

Published on November 24, 2020
Duration: 4:38

This video from Brownells, featuring Caleb and Steve, delves into the debate of whether older Smith & Wesson revolvers are superior to newer ones. The expert assessment highlights that while older models are excellent for collecting due to their historical features and build quality, newer revolvers often offer better performance for hard use and shooting. Advancements in materials, heat treatment, and manufacturing processes like MIM (though improved over early iterations) make modern S&W revolvers robust and accurate, particularly with features like tighter cylinder throats and the 'Endurance Package' on .44 Magnums. The conclusion is that both old and new S&W revolvers have their merits, with the choice depending on whether the primary purpose is collecting or frequent shooting.

Quick Summary

Experts from Brownells explain that while older Smith & Wesson revolvers are excellent for collectors due to historical features, newer models are superior for frequent shooting. Advancements in materials, heat treatment, and improved MIM parts make modern S&Ws more durable and accurate, especially with features like tighter cylinder throats and the 'Endurance Package'.

Chapters

  1. 00:04Introduction: Old vs. New S&W
  2. 00:19Collecting vs. Shooting S&W
  3. 00:41Features of Old S&W Revolvers
  4. 01:00Features of New S&W Revolvers
  5. 01:31Strength and Accuracy of New S&W
  6. 02:24Old S&W .45 Long Colt
  7. 02:49Conclusion: Both are good for purpose
  8. 03:00Internal Lock and Action Jobs
  9. 03:19Model Specific Preferences
  10. 03:45Final Thoughts and Recommendation

Frequently Asked Questions

Are older Smith & Wesson revolvers better than new ones?

Experts suggest that older Smith & Wesson revolvers excel for collecting due to their historical features like pinned barrels and recessed cylinders. However, for frequent shooting and hard use, newer models are often preferred due to advancements in materials, heat treatment, and improved manufacturing processes like MIM parts.

What are the key differences between old and new Smith & Wesson revolvers?

Older S&W revolvers are prized for their forged parts, pinned barrels, and recessed cylinders. Newer models benefit from improved alloys, heat treatment, and more reliable MIM components, often featuring tighter cylinder throats for enhanced accuracy and packages like the 'Endurance Package' for .44 Magnums.

Are MIM parts in new Smith & Wesson revolvers reliable?

While early MIM (Metal Injection Molding) parts had issues, modern MIM components used in new Smith & Wesson revolvers have significantly improved in strength and dependability, making them suitable for regular shooting and hard use.

Which Smith & Wesson revolvers are best for collecting versus shooting?

For collecting, classic S&W revolvers with features like pinned barrels and recessed cylinders are ideal. For shooting, newer models are generally recommended due to their robust construction, improved materials, and enhanced performance features, offering better durability for frequent use.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Brownells, Inc.

View all →