Calling the Shots | Alien Gear Holsters

Published on January 16, 2020
Duration: 47:22

This video, 'Calling the Shots' from Alien Gear Holsters, features Andrew Branca of Law of Self Defense discussing the five core elements of self-defense law: Innocence, Imminence, Proportionality, Avoidance, and Reasonableness. Branca emphasizes that understanding these elements is crucial for lawful use of force and avoiding criminal liability. He explains each element in detail, providing examples and clarifying common misconceptions, stressing that self-defense is a binary concept with no middle ground. The discussion highlights the importance of acting within legal boundaries to ensure protection under the law when carrying a firearm.

Quick Summary

The five essential elements of self-defense law are Innocence, Imminence, Proportionality, Avoidance, and Reasonableness. These principles dictate when the use of force is legally justified, emphasizing that the threat must be immediate, the force proportionate, and the actions reasonable, while also considering the duty to retreat and the defender's role as an initial aggressor.

Chapters

  1. 00:57Introduction & Technical Difficulties
  2. 01:15Welcome to Alien Gear Live
  3. 01:22Guest Andrew Branca Intro
  4. 02:18Cheers and Mug Comment
  5. 02:35Downloadable Resource: 5 Elements of Self-Defense Law
  6. 03:00What are the 5 Elements?
  7. 04:14Discussing the 5 Elements
  8. 04:24State Law Variations vs. Underlying Principles
  9. 05:55The 5 Elements Listed
  10. 06:55Element 1: Innocence
  11. 11:03Initial Aggressor Scenario
  12. 12:47Simplicity vs. Complexity of Self-Defense
  13. 15:36Question: Deadly Force Measurement
  14. 15:54Element 3: Proportionality
  15. 19:16Mace/Pepper Spray Example
  16. 21:12Question: Dogs and Force
  17. 22:20Dog Scenarios Breakdown
  18. 23:01Defending Your Dog (Property)
  19. 23:57Attacked by a Dog (Necessity)
  20. 25:53Dog as a Weapon
  21. 27:35Element 2: Imminence
  22. 30:29Element 4: Avoidance (Duty to Retreat)
  23. 32:07Castle Doctrine
  24. 34:04Question: Disabled Person's Rights
  25. 34:43Element 5: Reasonableness
  26. 39:08Reducing Physical and Legal Risks
  27. 41:20The Law of Self-Defense Book
  28. 43:46Appreciation and Book Promotion
  29. 44:26Upcoming Live Show at SHOT Show
  30. 44:46Contest & Raffle Reminder
  31. 45:20Andrew Branca at SHOT Show
  32. 45:29Viewer Comments & Book Giveaway
  33. 46:04Show Hiatus and Future Episodes
  34. 46:11Andrew Branca at SHOT Show (Personal)
  35. 46:32Closing Remarks & Safe Carry Message
  36. 46:46Alien Gear Holsters New Year Promotion

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the five elements of self-defense law?

The five core elements of self-defense law are Innocence (not being the initial aggressor), Imminence (the threat being immediate or in progress), Proportionality (using force equal to the threat), Avoidance (duty to retreat if safe), and Reasonableness (actions being those of a reasonable person). Understanding these is crucial for lawful use of force.

Can I use deadly force to defend my pet?

Legally, pets are considered personal property. You can generally only use non-deadly force to defend property. Only Texas has specific provisions for deadly force in defense of property, but it comes with strict conditions. For most states, defending a pet requires non-deadly force.

What is the difference between self-defense and the doctrine of necessity?

Self-defense law governs the use of force against another human being. The doctrine of necessity justifies actions that might otherwise be unlawful, like breaking a car window to save a child from a hot car, or using force against an animal to prevent greater harm to yourself, as it's about avoiding a larger harm by committing a smaller one.

Does the law require me to retreat before defending myself?

Only about 13 states impose a legal duty to retreat before using force in self-defense, and only if safe retreat is possible without increasing your risk. Most states are 'stand your ground' states, meaning you are not legally required to retreat, though failing to do so might be argued as unreasonable conduct.

Related News

All News →

More Self Defense Videos You Might Like

More from Alien Gear Holsters

View all →