Factory Ammo vs Reloads for Self Defense

Published on May 8, 2021
Duration: 15:58

This video compares factory self-defense ammunition against hand-loaded equivalents, focusing on performance metrics like velocity and energy. The presenter, an experienced handloader, discusses the potential legal ramifications of using reloaded ammunition in a self-defense scenario but highlights the benefits of cost-effective practice and enhanced quality control. The comparison includes 9mm 124-grain Gold Dots and .380 ACP 90-grain XTPs, with chronograph data presented for both calibers.

Quick Summary

Hand-loaded ammunition can be a cost-effective way to practice with self-defense rounds, potentially offering comparable or superior ballistics to factory loads. However, legal experts caution that using reloads in a self-defense incident could be used against you in court, as it might be argued you manufactured a deadly weapon.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & Disclaimer
  2. 00:29Handloads vs. Factory Loads for Self-Defense
  3. 01:25Legal Concerns with Handloaded Ammo
  4. 03:11Pros of Carrying Handloads
  5. 05:31Testing Setup & Methodology
  6. 06:189mm Gold Dot Chronograph Results
  7. 07:409mm Handload Chronograph Results
  8. 08:19.380 ACP Factory Chronograph Results
  9. 09:06.380 ACP Handload Chronograph Results
  10. 09:47Data Analysis: 9mm Performance
  11. 10:43Data Analysis: .380 ACP Performance
  12. 11:46Cost & Performance Takeaways
  13. 12:20Personal Choice: Handloads vs. Factory
  14. 13:14Risk vs. Reward of Handloads
  15. 14:03Conclusion & Final Thoughts

Frequently Asked Questions

Can hand-loaded ammunition be used for self-defense?

While technically possible, using hand-loaded ammunition for self-defense carries potential legal risks. Some argue it could be construed as manufacturing a deadly weapon, potentially used against you in court. However, the presenter suggests that in a justified shooting, the ammo type is less critical than the circumstances.

What are the advantages of using hand-loaded ammunition for self-defense practice?

Hand-loading allows for cost-effective practice with ammunition that closely mimics your chosen self-defense rounds. This is often more affordable than frequently shooting expensive premium factory defensive ammunition, enabling better familiarity with recoil and feeding characteristics.

How does hand-loaded ammunition compare to factory ammunition in performance?

In tests, hand-loaded ammunition can match or exceed factory loads in velocity and energy. For example, hand-loaded .380 ACP rounds showed higher velocity and energy than factory equivalents. Handloads can also offer greater consistency, as seen in the tighter velocity spread during testing.

What are the potential legal downsides of carrying hand-loaded self-defense ammunition?

A significant legal concern is that prosecutors might argue you manufactured a deadly weapon or intentionally made it more lethal, which could be used to imply intent or premeditation in a self-defense case. This is a controversial point with varying legal interpretations.

Related News

All News →

More Self Defense Videos You Might Like

More from The Gun Dungeon

View all →