Federal Punch vs CCI Stingers

Published on June 4, 2023
Duration: 14:29

This guide details a ballistic gel testing procedure comparing Federal Punch and CCI Stinger .22 LR ammunition. The expert analysis, from Iraqveteran8888, focuses on terminal ballistics, including penetration and wound cavity, across both handgun and rifle platforms. The findings help determine the optimal application for each ammunition type based on performance data.

Quick Summary

Iraqveteran8888's expert analysis reveals Federal Punch .22 LR excels in handguns, achieving 19.5 inches of penetration with a solid wound channel. Conversely, CCI Stinger .22 LR performs best in rifles, offering superior expansion and velocity (1572 fps) for varmint hunting, though with less penetration (11.5 inches).

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Punch vs. Stinger .22 LR
  2. 00:51Test Firearms: S&W M&P 22 Compact & Tippmann M4 Elite
  3. 01:28Velocity and Energy Data Comparison
  4. 02:08Projectile Design & Gel Setup
  5. 03:21Handgun Gel Test Results
  6. 06:01Rifle Gel Test Results
  7. 11:09Final Analysis & Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

Which .22 LR ammunition is better for handguns: Federal Punch or CCI Stinger?

For handguns, Federal Punch .22 LR is generally recommended due to its superior penetration (19.5 inches in gel) compared to CCI Stinger (12 inches). This deeper penetration is crucial for self-defense effectiveness from shorter barrels.

How does CCI Stinger .22 LR perform differently in a rifle compared to a handgun?

In a rifle, CCI Stinger .22 LR achieves higher velocity (1572 fps) and exhibits significant expansion, creating a large temporary cavity. However, its penetration is limited to 11.5 inches, making it ideal for varmint hunting but less so for deep penetration needs.

What are the key differences in bullet design between Federal Punch and CCI Stinger .22 LR?

Federal Punch .22 LR features a Flat Nose Solid projectile, designed for reliable feeding and deep penetration. CCI Stinger .22 LR uses a Copper-Plated Hollow Point (CPHP) bullet, engineered to expand upon impact for increased wound effects.

What ballistic gel results indicate Federal Punch is better for handguns?

Federal Punch's handgun gel test showed 19.5 inches of penetration with a significant permanent wound channel, despite a smaller temporary cavity. This depth is critical for ensuring effectiveness from the lower velocities of handgun-fired .22 LR rounds.

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from Iraqveteran8888

View all →