Fisticuffs!...9MM vs .40S&W Federal Punch Self-Defense AMMO Ballistic Gel Test!

Published on September 6, 2024
Duration: 13:34

This video presents a ballistic gel test comparing Federal Punch 9mm (124gr) and .40 S&W (165gr) self-defense ammunition. The test, conducted with a heavy clothing barrier, reveals performance data including velocity, expansion, and penetration. The instructor, with experience in firearms testing, highlights the differences in performance between the two calibers and ammunition types, offering insights into their effectiveness for self-defense.

Quick Summary

In a ballistic gel test with a heavy clothing barrier, Federal Punch 9mm (124gr) averaged 1,074 ft/s from a 3.1" barrel, expanding to 0.681" and penetrating 17.25". The .40 S&W (165gr) averaged 1,093 ft/s from a ~3.5" barrel, expanding to 0.635" and penetrating 19.75", showing good performance from short barrels.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & Setup
  2. 00:47Ammunition Overview: Federal Punch 9mm & .40 S&W
  3. 01:32Cartridge Comparison
  4. 02:02Firearm Selection: Short Barrels
  5. 02:329mm Pistol: Canik Mete MC9
  6. 02:37.40 S&W Pistol: Glock 27
  7. 02:55Velocity Testing: 9mm
  8. 04:30Velocity Testing: .40 S&W
  9. 05:59Ballistic Gel Test: Firing Sequence
  10. 06:35Gel Test Results: 9mm & .40 S&W
  11. 07:05Gel Analysis: Disruption & Expansion
  12. 08:37Penetration Depths
  13. 08:55Front View Close-up
  14. 09:19Top View Analysis
  15. 09:30Projectile Examination
  16. 10:30Projectile Weight & Size Measurements
  17. 11:18Conclusion: Federal Punch Performance
  18. 11:40Caliber Comparison Discussion
  19. 12:31Final Verdict: Winners & Adequacy
  20. 13:19Outro & Call to Action

Frequently Asked Questions

What were the measured velocities for Federal Punch 9mm and .40 S&W from short barrels?

The Federal Punch 9mm (124gr) averaged 1,074 ft/s from a 3.1-inch barrel. The Federal Punch .40 S&W (165gr) averaged 1,093 ft/s from a ~3.5-inch barrel. Both were lower than advertised velocities from 4-inch barrels.

How did Federal Punch 9mm and .40 S&W perform in ballistic gel with a clothing barrier?

Both rounds showed good expansion and penetration. The 9mm expanded to 0.681 inches and penetrated 17.25 inches, while the .40 S&W expanded to 0.635 inches and penetrated 19.75 inches, demonstrating effective self-defense characteristics.

Did the Federal Punch 9mm or .40 S&W show better expansion in the gel test?

Interestingly, the 9mm Federal Punch exhibited a larger final diameter (0.681 inches) and a wider disruption area in the gel compared to the .40 S&W (0.635 inches), despite the .40 S&W having more advertised energy.

What firearms were used for the Federal Punch ballistic gel test?

The test utilized a Canik Mete MC9 with a 3.1-inch barrel for the 9mm ammunition and a Glock 27 with a ~3.5-inch barrel for the .40 S&W ammunition, focusing on performance from short defensive pistol barrels.

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from Tools&Targets

View all →