Five-shot S&W vs .38 Special — why 9mm backup makes sense

Published on February 20, 2026
Duration: 1:19

The video discusses the merits of a Smith & Wesson 9mm revolver, comparing it to the .38 Special. The speaker suggests that five rounds of 9mm can be superior to .38 Special and that a 9mm revolver, similar in size to a Model 60, makes sense as a backup to a 9mm pistol, especially for magazine compatibility if the primary firearm fails.

Quick Summary

A 9mm revolver can be a practical backup firearm, especially when considering magazine compatibility with a primary 9mm pistol. This allows for potential use of magazines if the primary firearm malfunctions, such as a broken trigger bar. The size is comparable to a Smith & Wesson Model 60.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Smith & Wesson 9mm Revolver Discussion
  2. 00:309mm Backup Gun Rationale

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is a 9mm revolver considered a good backup gun?

A 9mm revolver can be an effective backup firearm because it allows for the potential use of magazines from a primary 9mm handgun if the main firearm malfunctions. This magazine compatibility offers a practical advantage in critical situations.

How does a 9mm revolver compare to a .38 Special?

The speaker suggests that five rounds of 9mm in a revolver can be superior to .38 Special. The size is comparable to a Smith & Wesson Model 60, and the 9mm option offers magazine interchangeability with a primary 9mm pistol.

What is the advantage of a .357 Magnum over a 9mm revolver?

While discussing 9mm revolvers, the speaker notes that acquiring the same firearm platform chambered in .357 Magnum provides greater power and versatility, making it a potentially more advantageous choice.

What practical failure scenario makes a 9mm backup gun useful?

If the trigger bar breaks on a primary 9mm handgun, a 9mm backup revolver becomes highly useful. The ability to use the same magazines as the primary firearm is a key benefit in such a malfunction scenario.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →