S&W Carry Comp 2.0 vs Walther PDP (Which is the Best?)

Published on March 13, 2025
Duration: 34:23

This video compares the Smith & Wesson M&P Carry Comp 2.0 and the Walther PDP through a series of tests including accuracy, speed drills, an FBI qualification course, and a rigorous torture test involving water, silt, sand, and mud. The Walther PDP ultimately demonstrated superior reliability in the torture test, experiencing fewer malfunctions and recovering more effectively from contamination.

Quick Summary

The Walther PDP proved more reliable than the Smith & Wesson M&P Carry Comp 2.0 in extreme torture tests involving water, silt, sand, and mud. While both pistols performed well in accuracy and FBI qualification drills, the PDP showed fewer malfunctions and better recovery from contamination, making it the preferred choice for harsh conditions.

Chapters

  1. 00:08Introduction: Battle of the Guns
  2. 01:42Ammo Function Test: Smith & Wesson
  3. 04:50Ammo Function Test: Walther PDP
  4. 07:57Speed Drills: Control & Speed
  5. 11:04FBI Qualification: Smith & Wesson
  6. 16:36FBI Qualification: Walther PDP
  7. 21:42Torture Test: Smith & Wesson
  8. 25:57Torture Test: Walther PDP
  9. 31:09Final Comparison & Verdict

Frequently Asked Questions

Which pistol is more reliable in extreme conditions: the Smith & Wesson M&P Carry Comp 2.0 or the Walther PDP?

In a comprehensive torture test involving submersion in water, silt, sand, and mud, the Walther PDP demonstrated superior reliability. It experienced fewer malfunctions compared to the Smith & Wesson M&P Carry Comp 2.0 and recovered more effectively from contamination, making it the preferred choice for harsh environments.

How did the Smith & Wesson M&P Carry Comp 2.0 and Walther PDP perform in an FBI qualification course?

Both the Smith & Wesson M&P Carry Comp 2.0 and the Walther PDP successfully completed the FBI qualification course. This involved timed drills from various distances and positions, indicating that both firearms are capable for duty or self-defense applications and meet rigorous performance standards.

What were the key differences noted between the S&W Carry Comp 2.0 and the Walther PDP?

The primary differences highlighted were the S&W M&P Carry Comp 2.0's compensated barrel, designed to reduce recoil, versus the Walther PDP's non-compensated design. Additionally, the Walther PDP showed greater resilience during extreme torture testing involving mud and sand contamination.

What kind of ammunition was used in the comparison tests between the S&W Carry Comp 2.0 and Walther PDP?

A variety of ammunition types were used, including 115-grain Tula, Winchester frangible, 115-grain Blazer, 115-grain Hornady Critical Defense, 124-grain Hornady Critical Defense, 124-grain Federal Premium, and 124-grain Winchester. Both pistols functioned flawlessly with all tested rounds during initial function tests.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from USCCA

View all →